I think tire size run also plays a big part of the effectiveness. Oversized tires, especially wide ones, can create more rolling resistance and gas consumption while reducing the running RPM/speed ratio (and speedometer) full time (like a 4:1 gear). An OD is also another "moving part" to maintain for consideration. Every modification usually comes with a "compromise" to fit the "owner's specific need/desire" for the modification.
HP was mentioned with the "ideal 4:1 ratio", which made me wonder... how does the approximate "2200 RPM Torque Max" rating fit in to the equation, if it does at all? Thanks.