I've always had good success with the Felpro (Made in the USA) head gasket coated lightly in copper spray. It is a composite/steel combination.
Many in the Willys world seem to like the 100% copper head gasket offered by a few of the better Willys parts vendors. They are a bit pricey for me when considering my success with the Felpo gasket.
There is a specific order used when torquing the head bolts/studs/nuts. Follow this rule. There is a map available on the world wide web.
Also, after the replacement, get the engine up to full temperature, let it cool back down, then re-torque the head. Some folks forget to do this important step.