If you use a key start, or a push button start you need the solenoid. This is because the starter circuit draws way more current than the key switch or the push button can handle. So you have to have a secondary circuit, the first turns on the ignition with a key, provides power to the coil and to the solenoid, the secondary circuit flows through the solenoid to provid power to the starter, this way you don't burn up the small switches that control the ignition.
With the foot starter the switch that controls the starting circuit is manually operated by your foot, so you don't need the secondary circuit. Lots simpler to wire, ancdCarl is right, not many people remember or know about the starter button, and on the 3A you can't really see it very well.