The paint charts usually show all the colors for all the Willys vehicles. CJs were only available in some of the colors listed. Looking at the 1951 paint chart from The CJ-3A Page
http://www.cj-3a.com/willys_paint_chips.htm you can see that regular 1951 CJ-3As were only available in Luzon Red, Potomac Gray or Emerald Green.
With that said there are always exceptions. Willys did paint CJ-3As other colors because the dealers complained about the limited color choices. So, the safe bet for 1951 is Luzon Red, Potomac Gray or Emerald Green, but other factory colors are possible.