The CJ3A Page CJ3B.info

Post reply

Warning: this topic has not been posted in for at least 120 days.
Unless you're sure you want to reply, please consider starting a new topic.

Note: this post will not display until it's been approved by a moderator.

Name:
Email:
Subject:
Message icon:

Verification:
Type the letters shown in the picture
Listen to the letters / Request another image

Type the letters shown in the picture:
Write the word between words Jeep from this JeepWILLYSJeep?:
How many slot has a GPW grill?  7 - 9 - 11:

shortcuts: hit alt+s to submit/post or alt+p to preview


Topic Summary

Posted by: oldtime
« on: November 17, 2014, 12:13:05 PM »

Quote
Was it Tumbleweed that had his tub "dipped" and plated? That sounds like a great solution, though it's not available everywhere....
The main problem with galvanic hot dipping is that it makes it very difficult and hazardous to weld repair things in the future.

Quote
There is always fiberglass. I built a fiberglass bodied CJ-3A many years ago.
I bought a Jewels full stainless CJ-3A body several years back and I'm still collecting a few parts for that build.

Quote
During testing the M-38 was considered underpowered compared to the MB, the only thing that made it squeak by was going with 5.38 axle ratio. Add 12HP with the F-head engine (M-38A1) and then things were acceptable.
I can fully appreciate that.
Other than 1 notable exception I have driven old jeeps as daily drivers since the mid 1970's.

I drove a near stock standard Go-Devil powered CJ-2A without O.D. back when the national speed limit was 55.
At the time it was very marginally acceptable on cross country trips of 500 miles per day.
I always keep my Willys engines in good shape and I'm not afraid to run them long and hard.

In the early 1980's the speed limit went up.
I was basically forced to convert to a Hurricane for practical reasons.
So I rebuilt a pristine CJ-3B with 25% overdrive.
For multiple reasons I feel that the Hurricanes as daily drivers are very marginal by todays standards.

I am currently still running a Hurricane as a daily driver but will soon convert to Dauntless power for increased practicality.

All Jeeps were originally derived from the 1940 military build stipulations
It's a pity that I have not studied the Military jeeps in greater depth.
I am however, very familiar with every significant change that occurred from 1945 CJ to 1985 CJ.

My point is that the original WWII Military LRV was re-introduced to the public in 1945 as a "UNIVERSAL".
That Universal design underwent a constant state of change that we generally consider to be progress.
For whatever reasons some of the changes did deviate away from the original military stipulations.

My Jeep interest is to KNOW all changes 1941- 1985 and beyond that I determine what was true progress.

Considering my own optimum JEEP build stipulations I have the tremendous advantage of oversight or hindsight.
I can see all the changes and determine what was truly progressive.

Considering the "L" in LRV, I see no significant body progress beyond the CJ-3A� form.

And so I feel obliged to claim the M-38 / CJ-3A body form was the all time superior "Universal" design.
Obviously I am considering mass produced jeeps and eliminating the rare prototypes.
But it is very shrewd to be aware of the prototypes and possible body deviations from standard.


Posted by: 1955CJ-5
« on: November 16, 2014, 08:24:16 PM »

Great picture Ryan!

I have a couple of the frame tie-down footman loops and they must be nearly a pound each, and there were at least four, maybe six on the M-38...the half loop bumpers, the extra battery....the fording equipment...

It all adds up....

What is the weight difference anyway?...I'll start searching....

The M38 was listed at about.........2750
I found the CJ-3a weight listed as 2205

A difference of ...........................545......That is the 1/4 ton capacity of the 3a!
Posted by: Ryan_M
« on: November 16, 2014, 07:05:15 PM »

Quote
How about the voltage regulator. It was so heavy it had to be mounted to the frame.


The 3A voltage regulator is less than 1.5 lbs. The M38 equivalent is nearly 9lbs. The cable that comes out of it is about the size of a garden hose. Pretty much�everything - except the motor -� was bigger, badder, and much heavier.



Posted by: Bob W
« on: November 16, 2014, 05:26:18 PM »

Quote
What in the M 38 made it so much heavier?  I know about reinforced tailgate, different top, removeable pan, etc...but it seems I must be missing something heavy.

There is no one item that was really heavy, but everything adds up. It doesn't take much weight to make a huge difference in performance when we only have 60HP on a good day. The electrical system alone added a lot of weight. The military was trying to develop vehicles with interchangeable components to ease parts supply. Just pick up a military tail light and compare it to the civilian type. A Patton tank used the same tail light. How about the voltage regulator. It was so heavy it had to be mounted to the frame. The list goes on and on. During testing the M-38 was considered underpowered compared to the MB, the only thing that made it squeak by was going with 5.38 axle ratio. Add 12HP with the F-head engine (M-38A1) and then things were acceptable.
Posted by: athawk11
« on: November 16, 2014, 10:16:16 AM »

"Original 3A body compared to modifications for improvement"

I think a good place to start would be the advancements that have happened to the modern Jeep.

Better paint finishes and undercoating.

And it�s hard to argue with the design change to the fender.� Even the soldiers of WWII knew the flat fender was flawed�

�

Don�t beat up on me.� I like the look of the flat fender as much as the next guy.� Just trying to stay within the context of this discussion.

Tim
Posted by: F Bill
« on: November 16, 2014, 08:41:39 AM »

Wow, this is an incredible thread.� I'm thinking we need to archive most of it in an article.

Oldtime said:

:So I ask you all what is it that the CJ-3A continues to excel at that no other Universal model can claim ?"


I haven't a clue what Oldtime� is referring to, but I do have a question for Bob W...What in the M 38 made it so much heavier?� I know about reinforced tailgate, different top, removeable pan, etc...but it seems I must be missing something heavy.

Only thing I can think of is the ability to drop in a later engine in these with the different motor mount design, but that can't be it as you still need to do hood modifications or get the short carb.� To me Universal seems to refer to the anyone can drive it for any purpose....and there were a whole lot of accessories by the time the 3A came around but they all would work on a 2A...

I know...the 3A body tub could be used for the fastest flatfender jeep in production, the king of the hill (paved, of course.. ;D) Dispatcher! :D
Posted by: Bob W
« on: November 12, 2014, 04:47:26 PM »

There is always fiberglass. I built a fiberglass bodied CJ-3A many years ago. The body did not rust, but everything else did (here in the rust belt). The military was experimenting with a "plastic" M-38. I'm assuming that was fiberglass. Still searching for more info about it.
Posted by: 1955CJ-5
« on: November 12, 2014, 12:30:24 PM »

Quote
The solution ???

Was it Tumbleweed that had his tub "dipped" and plated? That sounds like a great solution, though it's not available everywhere....
Posted by: oldtime
« on: November 12, 2014, 12:21:42 PM »

1955CJ-5,
A couple of good points.
The CJ-3B seats were not adjustable prior to 1961.
With minor changes one could easily install the late 3B seats into a 3A.
Willys Motors called them "bucket type" seats.
The 3A and the identical early 3B seats with the steel backs were called "1/3 type" seats.

Yes I suppose that rust is the obvious flaw that we nearly overlooked.
The solution ???
Did you hear in the recent news about Fords big gamble for the F-150 pickup series ?
All 2015 Ford F150's are scheduled to have aluminum bodies .
So what if we put an aluminum body on the CJ-3A ?
Will the aluminum be any more resistant to corrosion than steel ?
We will soon see as the new aluminum Fords will soon be on the road.

And would not an aluminum construction compliment the superior "light weight trait" of the CJ-3A body ?
Maybe and maybe not !
The Aquala aluminum bodies are rather thick. See: http://www.aqualu.com/jeep-bodies.html




Posted by: 1955CJ-5
« on: November 11, 2014, 09:08:15 PM »

Quote
So what all� design flaws do we see in the CJ-3A body ?

Besides being prone to rust?

But, really, we have mostly covered the shortcomings...

Poorly place spare tire, lack of a glovebox, no removable floor panel as in the M-38 and CJ-5's..etc...

how about the lack of an adjustable drivers seat....?
Posted by: oldtime
« on: November 11, 2014, 01:06:31 PM »

We have previously identified the CJ-3A as the lightest mass production universal jeep.
The CJ-3A's low hood and windshield design also provides for superior foreword visibility as compared to other the Jeeps.
It thereby becomes the optimum candidate for certain universal jeep builds.
I� state "certain builds"; because intended useage may dictate other priorities beyond lightness and visibility.

Example:
In my area we have lots of forested trails with mud, rocks and creeks to ford.
So here in the Ozarks the short lightweight jeep with high visability certainly reigns supreme.
In other open areas of the country like Moab; a longer wheel based universal may prove to be the superior off-road performer.
Every operator of the universal jeep should consider using the model and vintage of jeep that best suites their particular needs without need for modification.
For more extensive reading on Jeep modifications see: http://z4.invisionfree.com/CJ3B_Bulletin_Board/ar/t2591.htm

Stock 3A Bodies vs. Modified and Aftermarket 3A Bodies

In general; modifications may be implemented to correct a design flaw.
Modifications are also implemented so as to compliment an already existing trait.

So what all� design flaws do we see in the CJ-3A body ?
And what features can we reasonably or practically hope to correct or to compliment ?

After all, the jeep universal should always be envisioned as a complete and synchronous system.
The "complete synchronous system" directly implies that all individual components and assemblies should compliment one another.

Posted by: athawk11
« on: November 11, 2014, 10:25:51 AM »

Quote
...it should be recognized as supreme.

I agree! [smiley=thumbsup.gif]

Tim
Posted by: oldtime
« on: November 10, 2014, 09:17:04 PM »

Yes I agree it's a real chore lowering a 60 pound transmission that's bolted to a 70 pound transfer case down onto your chest.
That's why we plan ahead. Do it once and do it right.
So I must agree those are valid arguments in favor of the M38 removable floor pans.

That aside I use my jeeps for civilian functions and therefore I prefer CJ designation.

Guided by the topic title....  I believe we have found the CJ-3A to best fill the role of being the lightest universal type jeep ever put into mass production.
And for that single achievement it should be recognized as supreme.

Any more comments on that ?
Posted by: athawk11
« on: November 10, 2014, 07:37:04 PM »

Quote
You'd think after an early engineer had to change out his first transmission he would have broken out the reciprocating saw and immediately implemented a design change to all tubs.

Laugh out loud!� ;D
Posted by: Ryan_M
« on: November 10, 2014, 08:22:40 AM »

Quote
I wish Bretto or Ryan would chime in on the removable floor pan.�


It's night and day. I have removed and reinstalled a transmission/TC in my M38. The removable floor pans make it a relatively painless task. From being able to support the transmission from above to having easy access and visibility when inserting the input shaft into the back of the motor and bolting everything back up - it's a breeze. After completing the process on an M38 I dread having to attempt the same job on my 3A. And my 3A is a candidate for it since the transmission is leaking from pretty much everywhere.

Honestly, I'm surprised it took Willys so long to come up with this. You'd think after an early engineer had to change out his first transmission he would have broken out the reciprocating saw and immediately implemented a design change to all tubs.