I found this funky old altimeter years ago in an antique/junk store....
You can see that it does not have the kollsman window where you would set the barometric pressure...it is a non-sensitive altimeter....you just set the pointer to zero and then it gives you your altitude above ground level as you climb...
If you find one make sure it is for a basic pitot-static system and not one that requires an air data computer to operate..
You might check Aircraft Spruce, or maybe your local chapter of the EAA/Experimental Aircraft Assn...
Well I just looked at aircraft spruce..all they have is new and they are expensive!
you might try a local aircraft maintenance business....slightly damaged or used altimeters might be too expensive to repair and you might find one that is affordable
Maybe?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/ALTIMETER-/281883560095?hash=item41a191c89f:g:JOAAAOSwcOFWbJS9&vxp=mtr