Steve,
That's amazing. This looks like another example for your rant posted about parking lenses.
I've sent parts back. If I can't see the item and compare, especially if it's a questionable "guaranteed to fit your jeep" part, I'll pass. I can only imagine our vendors are being told it fits, they assume it will work and then the customer doesn't complain. Yes, I've had vendors respond to me with, "Well this is the first time I've heard of a problem!"
To the original poster, Tchara, this is a few years down the road. How did you fix this?