I did pick up a replacement from Napa. Their online picture looked similar to my cap. I was hoping I could use the seal off it. Turned out to be a workable 4lb cap, but the design is different.
I was up and running, (Tom, thanks for the tip) when, I believe, my water pump started to fail. (See Water Pump...When it Rains, it Pours)
As Bill suggested, I will try the suppliers for a new seal. I am hopeful.
I would like to know more about making seals. Matto, maybe you could post some info on this process.
Tim