My Willys 3A and 3B Community
3A, 3B, DJ Technical Knowledge Base => "Original"-- Technical Questions, Answers, Observations => Topic started by: BMIC on March 31, 2015, 07:20:21 AM
-
After a great week of a post build shake down rides I heard a pronounced snap in the transmission and now get a loud rattle in 1st gear only.
Still runs strong and shifts smoothly but needless to say the transmission needs to come out and be rebuilt.
Here comes the age old question, take off the grill and fenders and pull the engine/tranny/transfer or remove the tub?
Or as my wife suggests, close the garage door and leave it for a few weeks, your to frustrated to work on it right now....
-
I crawled under and took mine out from the bottom, didn't take long but had to lay on a creeper
-
That's a bummer. Sorry to hear that.
I'm at this stage right now. If I were after the clutch, I may choose to pull the engine.
If I'm after the transmission, I would pull the drive train from below, and leave the engine alone. The drive train has to be removed and disassembled anyway.
Tim
-
Boy that is discouraging to hear. Might be worth pulling the shift tower off to have a look inside the tranny first. Maybe by some miracle it's a problem that can be fixed without have to pull the whole thing out.
-
IF YOU PULL IT FROM UNDER THE JEEP, BE SURE TO PUT A JACK UNDER THE REAR OF THE ENGINE FIRST.
If it were me, I think I'd pull the whole drive train� since it is not certain exactly what broke.
PS: You need to stop doing wheelies!
-
New clutch, I could not resist...
Thanks for the advice gents, I will be dropping the Transmission/Transfer this weekend (after supporting the engine Mike S), I'll take some pictures of what broke.
-
PS... along with the good advice from my friends on this page there is always a PM for parts etc.... Thanks Ryan M for offering a whole T-90.
-
I was able to drop both the transmission and transfer case from under the jeep fairly smoothly on Saturday morning. I pulled the shift tower and saw the bad news right off. Two chipped teeth on the 1st gear and after draining the oil found 7 roller bearings at the bottom.
Not sure why the bearings came out but I am bringing the transmission to an antique auto restoration shop this morning to have it rebuilt.
One surprise was the condition of the oil, one side (clean) is what came out of the transfer case and the dirty came out of the transmission. It was over 2 years ago that I flushed (I thought I did) the old oil and replaced it with GL-1. Clearly I missed something in the process and it will be an expensive lesson.
-
OUCH! Expense aside, at least you know where the problem lies now. I'm curious - were the roller bearings rattling around in there before you disassembled everything or do you think they fell out when you removed the transfer case? It's easy to dislodge them if you're messing around back there with the shift tower off and the mainshaft not tied down. What's the ETA on the rebuild? Will you be back on the road this summer or are you out for the season now?
-
Yikes. Was this tranny ever opened by you ("post build") before the shake down ride? I would have to think either it never was or maybe when you rebuilt it, one or more of the 14 roller bearings got out of place. Those input and output shafts might be toast if the bearing surfaces got scored.
The difference in the oils means there is no open passage between the two boxes.
-
Tough luck. You'd just reached the point where you could drive around a bit and now this setback. This is the main reason I don't own an old Jeep, or any other old vehicle for that matter. You see, I can always drive you-know-who's. ;) The first time I drive the 3A this year I'll have the satisfaction of knowing it has a new water pump among other things--and the M has had an all new frame-----and I didn't have to do any work.
Good luck with you trans rebuild, and of course if you get back on the road I'm, er, only four miles away.....
-
The first drive I took when buying the jeep 5 years ago indicated that the transmission was strong and other than new seals and a oil change I could move on to more pressing issues which were many. When I took the first real drives in it about 3 weeks ago all seemed good. I was talking to Ryan M and saying that I was thrilled so far as 2 or 3 mile runs had produced only fuel gauge and speedometer issues. On one drive I herd a bang in the transmission follower by a rattleing. Obviously it was the bearing retainer (?) letting go and the rattling was the roller bearings.
At this point I would not like to spend the summer rebuilding and installing the transmission so I will send it out to be professionally done, and bypass my ability factor as well.
Seems after a long rebuild I just want to enjoy it now, the thoughts of making a mistake rebuilding the transmission and pulling it all out again will kill what should be a fun summer.
Given the oil issues I am anxious to find out if the transmission to transfer case passage was blocked as well.
-
Jeff M... Oddly enough the engine block that sat in your garage all those years preforms the best.
-
glad you found the problem. man, when you decide you're going to do something, you're fast! I probably would have suggested pulling the tub, but sounds like it went pretty smoothly just dropping the transmission. glad to hear. good luck!
-
Ryan's question is my question...
It would be hard to lose those roller bearings from the bore if everything was all buttoned up. How many total bearings did you find? Just wondering if "extras" were left behind at some point, or as Bretto mentions...During the assembly process on a rebuild, it's fairly easy to lose a few bearings without realizing it. Especially if you're fighting the output shaft past the cluster gear. Ask me how I know this. :-[
I wonder if you have the old style cases that didn't allow a flow of oil between the TC and Tranny.
Tim
-
Tim, I don't have any history of the jeep so I have no idea of any recent attempts to rebuild the transmission. The only indication of any problem was the pronounced bang followed by a rattling sound I experienced a few weeks ago. Given the limited miles I had on the jeep (8 to 10) it is possible a few had been loose all along and the bang was one (of 7 that I found) that finally got caught in the gears.
I have asked the shop rebuilding it to give me his thoughts on where and why it failed and will pass on the info as I get it.
"Old Style Case" is interesting as the rebuilder mentioned that not all 3A transmissions flowed oil to the transfer case. Can anyone tell be the markings?
-
the rebuilder mentioned that not all 3A transmissions flowed oil to the transfer case.
If nothing else it's encouraging that your rebuilder knows this. Sounds like you found the right guy for the job.
-
the rebuilder mentioned that not all 3A transmissions flowed oil to the transfer case.
If nothing else it's encouraging that your rebuilder knows this. Sounds like you found the right guy for the job.
Agreed. A very good sign.
I looked at my cases. I don't know if this is a clue, but neither T-90 has the cast #4 or the Q (?) Where this 4 and Q are, I have one small #2...concave, not raised lettering.
Both T-90 cases have the full date on the date tag. 12-4-50 and 5-10-48. Yours has, what appears to be, just the month and date...no year.
The two TC cases I can look at: Both have the C18-15-10 8 that you show, but one has raised letters, the other has concave letters. Neither have the raised G. The case with the concave numbers also has a concave S, but much lower on that same face.
I know, I haven't helped at all, but it's interesting none the less. Just wanted to throw out the differences. Maybe we can get a few more guys to chime in.
Tim
-
What are the stamped assembly dates?
-
Bob, On my two TC cases...tough call. Pretty hard to see. I think I'm seeing R8-5 on the case with concave part number. On the case with raised part number...A7-9
BMIC, you might find this on the same face shown in your photo, but lower down under the part number. It's a small tag that looks like the 10-30 tag on your T-90 case.
-
R8-5 doesn't fit the expected pattern. A7-9 January 7, 1949.
-
The only other markings I can find is the 9 25 cast in the attached picture. I do remember seeing some stamped numbers on top of the transmission under the shift tower plate. I'll get a picture this morning and see if that gives any further clue to the case style and age.
-
I stopped at the shop that is working on my transmission this morning to see if there were anymore identifying numbers stamped or cast into the case. On the top of the case there are the letter/numbers L 62 3, that makes no sense to me but maybe to Bob W?
The shop is a one man operation and to the novice it looks like total confusion. Although Bob (owner) has not got into the transmission yet he said the problem was clear. On a recent rebuild not all the bearings were seated when the shaft was inserted and were at the bottom waiting to be picked up into the gears. After he wiggled the shaft and revealed the play that became obvious. I know Tim, Ryan, and others have highlighted that issue many times previous.
Interesting picture attached, my trans/TC on a bench between a Lotus head and a MGB block. I could walk around this shop all day....
-
Really sounds like you've got this thing in the right hands. Wish I could find a shop like this.
When inserting my output shaft, I used a ton of Vaseline to hold the roller bearings in place, but what seemed weird...while trying to insert the output shaft in to position, the end of the shaft seemed to have a magnetic quality. It would occasionally bring the roller bearing back out with it while I was positioning the shaft. Because of this, I lost a couple bearings to the bottom of the case. I grabbed them, stuck them back in and loaded them with more Vaseline. I can see how someone might have done this without noticing they lost a bearing or two.
Tim
-
L 62 3
November 6, 1952
-
L 62 3
November 6, 1952
Explain please...
November is the 11th month
"L" is the 12th letter..
Did they not use the "I"?
The shop that did my engine was like that....chaos to anyone but the owner. I loved to just walk around and look at things....
-
L 62 3
November 6, 1952
Explain please...
November is the 11th month
"L" is the 12th letter..
Did they not use the "I"?
Typically the letters I and O are not used in coding systems because they look too much like the numbers 1 and 0.
Excluding the letter "I" makes November the 11th letter. The next one or two digits is the day, 6th in this case. Then comes a single digit for the year. 2 could be 1952 or 1962. The last digit is still an unknown to me. Seems like it is always a low numeral.
-
The last digit is still an unknown to me. Seems like it is always a low numeral.
Any chance it could be 1st, 2nd, or 3rd shift?
-
That's certainly a possibility.
-
Transmission rebuilt and installed. With the help of my son (it is a 2 man job) we installed the Trans/TFC and hooked back up the clutch, drive shafts, speedometer and e-brake. Sunday morning I drove it on the street for the first time to the local coffee shop to get the "professional opinion" of the local guys. Nothing carries more respect than an old Willy's Jeep.
Transmission felt great, worked great. A mental punch list of things to do: Steering has just a little too much play, Speedometer bouncing wildly, and replace fuel tank sending unit. Timing and some carb adjusting.
-
That some good news there! Sounds like you are well on your way to a very nice driver. You'll be chasing the fine tuning for months but that part is much more fun than hoisting transmissions in and out.
If you don't have them already, pick up a dwell meter and vacuum gauge. Both are well worth the small amount they cost.