My Willys 3A and 3B Community
3A, 3B, DJ Technical Knowledge Base => "Original"-- Technical Questions, Answers, Observations => Topic started by: aboyandhisdog on July 24, 2014, 11:52:26 PM
-
It's been a while since I serviced my air filter, but I have always wondered how, exactly, do these things work? I have the "FGA Oil Washed Air Cleaner" maintenance sheet, but it doesn't go into just how it works. It talks about how it "condenses oil from the airstream" but I am trying to understand just what that means. Does anyone know? Gunslinger...?
-
They basically work in that they rely on the quick changing in air flow direction.� As the air comes in, it heads downward toward the oil sump, then the air turns 180*.� With the dirt having the downward direction velocity and more weight than the air, it tends to keep going down and hits and sticks to the oil.
Right guys?
-
Your are exactly right, Bretto. 8-)
-
For the second time this week I'll contribute an informative link from Bob W's site. Here's a solid run-down on how these filters work:
http://www.cj3a.info/tech/aircleaner.html
Pretty much how Bretto described it with a little more detail. Good stuff.
-
Yup, that is a really good tutorial on air cleaners and how they work. One thing that you should remember is that the Air Cleaner on the Willys is made with a non-removable screen, the service instructions for the FGA I believe reference a removable screen. If you do want to clean the screen, flushing with kerosene is still a good method, just let it sit for a while to drain before you re-install. As for the author of that article, I know he interviewed several Donaldson Engineers in order to develop it, in fact a Donaldson Product Manager reviewed that article for accuracy as well. Yeh it was me....I sell filters for Donaldson.
-
I knew there was a Donaldson guy rattling around the forums but I forgot it was you Gunslinger. That helps explain your recent European business trip as well. I was curious what you were up to over there, besides guzzling wine on the company credit card ;D
-
Thanks everybody. I guess I need to start going to Bob's site first from now on. How does the screen become treated with oil? Just from driving, or do we need to oil it upon assembly?
-
Ryan ... ;D ;D ;D
Aboyandhis dog,
Just fill the oil cup to the prescribed level when you put it back together, as the engine compartment heats up the oil becomes less viscous and will splash up on the screen, oil vapors will also re-coalesce on the screen as well. The screen then traps dirt in the oil and contains it from moving to the carb. If you look into the oil cup, you will see that there are a couple of different chambers, these are for the purpose of containing the dirt sediment and keeping the oil somewhat clear of debris.
One note of interest, in 1942 the Army was having all kinds of trouble with engine dusting in North Africa. Frank Donaldson was called to Washington along with a bunch of other experts to solve the problem.. result, the M4A Sherman was outfitted with a Donaldson Oil Bath Air cleaner very similar to the one on the Willys. In about 1989 we designed and installed a self cleaning air cleaner for the M1A1 Abrams, in desert trials the service interval went from 20 miles to 200 miles. Boy they liked that!!!! Now I can get you one of these if you like, they are just a little larger than your jeep, weigh a little more, are armour plated, and cost abotu $20,000, if you buy in bulk !!! :o :o
-
$20,000 really? Got to love the way our government spends our money.
-
What the heck, its a 3 million dollar tank!!! If you do the math it may come out exactly right, $4,000 dollar jeep, $50.00 air cleaner, 3 million dollar jeep (with gun) $20K air cleaner!!!! ;D ;D
-
HHHHHHMMMMMmmmmmmmmmm, so what's a Donaldson hammer cost the government ;D
Lee ;)
-
Gun, I think it is very impressive that you can make an air filter for a tank...I see those things operate on TV and the dust they kick up, and am amazed anything can filter that air. I can see what a problem it would be to get clean air to them.
Back to the L134...seems the faster the engine is turning, the better the filtration. Is there still good filtration at idle and low rpm's? Just curious.
-
Boy and dog,
The way these are designed the air flow has very little to do with efficiency. Remember gravity is the driving force at low air flows and inertia is the driving force at higher air flows. The other thing to consider is the size of the dust. Gasoline engines can take dust up to about 5 micron in diameter before any damage is done, diesels not so, they get hammered with 1 tablespoon of 2 micron dust, that will cost you a rebuild.
So at low air flow the heavy dust comes into the air cleaner; and there is not enough air flow to carry it around the corner to the wire mesh. So it just drops out, at higher air flows the dust has so much momentum that the heavy particles are running like a Babe Ruth home run and smash into the oil bath where they get trapped. The lighter stuff makes the corner but gets mixed up with the oil vapor and either attaches to the screen or takes on the weight of the oil and drops out.
Every filter uses several different filtration mechanisms in concert to make them work: sieving, impaction, gravi-metrical separation, and some others that I only remember at work. Air Cleaners are designed for a range of air flows which are designed to protect the engine at all of the flows it will see. Some things to look at on your air cleaner are all of the different sizes and shapes, Perforated inlet at the fire wall, behind air cleaner at the firewall (tough place for dirt to get to, large inlet area slows down the air and the big ones don't get carried in). The 90 degree turn above the oil bath, (big ones can't make the turn) tortuous path through the screen, large body at the the screen, (slows down the air at high flow) in order to capture particles. One other thing to remember, at very low air flows (Idle) your air flow is so low that it will have a hard time picking up the big 5 micron dust particles that cause damage. Kind of like a vacuum cleaner with a plugged bag, no sucky no dirty !
When you look at the air cleaner remember that every aspect of it is designed with air and dirt in mind. Imagine a river with a log in it, that log is dust, the air cleaners job is to separate the log from the river. Pretty much the same thing.
I got windy, I apologize.
-
Gun,
Not to divert too far from topic, but I find this thread really interesting! It seems the oil bath air filter does a very good job of cleaning the incoming air. Why did the OEM's make the switch to paper filters? Ease of assembly on the line? Source of revenue after the sale (replacement filters)? Better performance? Oil vapor in the airstream causing problems with MAF sensors? Fuel economy? Space constraints in the engine bay?
This is the kind of weird, interesting info that sticks in my brain!
-
I got windy, I apologize.
Hey no apologies needed.
I love this kind of in-depth, tech stuff.
Keep up the great flow of info.
And I second macrisel's questions. I'm curious about all those issues as well.
-
The change to paper filters was for the most part a technical improvement over the oil bath.� Oil bath air cleaners provide about 85% efficiency on 5 micron dust.� By switching to paper we were able to develop systems that provide up to 99% efficiency on 2 micron dust.� Remember the diesel engine began to become a dominant player about 1960, then the turbo came on line as well.� As we discussed earlier, diesels will fail if they ingest 1 table spoon of 2 micron dust.� Just for comparison, a human hair is 40 microns in diameter.� Additionally the paper filter allows us to develop a media for a specific application.� We us different types of cellulose media, papyrus, switch grass.. all kinds of stuff, then the synthetics came along, they allow us to develop medias for specific chemical or weather environments. One of our really cool medias is a nano fiber overlay for cellulose that improves efficiency to 99.9%� It also makes a great base for growing replacement cellular structures for human cells.�This is an experimental project that was based on growing new skin for burn victims. �Gotta go, plane landing.� more later.
Back. Paper elements also allowed us to develop air cleaners with more effective integral pre- cleaners, as well as being able to make horizontal air cleaners rather than just vertical ones. And yes, they do provide a revenue stream, kind of like the razor blade model, buy my air cleaner once and you are going to have to buy my filters for as long as you own that machine. ;) ;) ;)
-
And yes, they do provide a revenue stream, kind of like the razor blade model, buy my air cleaner once and you are going to have to buy my filters for as long as you own that machine.� ;) ;) ;)
Ah yes, the Xerox Model.
Xerox doesn't make a living off of copy machines, nor does Hewlett Packard live off of printers. They both live off the sales of toner cartridges.
I bought a new HP color laser printer a couple years back for only $200 (thank you Amazon). I just bought a 4-color toner pack - for $200! I was very, very tempted to just buy another printer from Amazon. :o :P
-
Ok, so on this path how could you add a snorkle to a jeep? I was sort of thinking about making some sort of manifold to cover the intake holes on the oil bath that had a pipe fitting on there. Then a snorkle out the hood with one of those whirlwind pre filters.
But military jeeps had snorkels and I'm assuming they kept the oil bath. How did they go about it?
-
The filter was the same, but different of course.....it had a fitting on the side for the snorkel attachment...
http://www.willysjeepparts.com/Fuel_Images/1204E4.jpg
-
Actually when I do this I will probably make a canister for a filter and leave my stock one alone. And buy a new hood. And now my comments are pretty much irrelevant to the subject.
-Jesse
-
Jesse,
M38 air cleaner, M38 Hood, M38 Snorkel, Donaldson top spin HD pre-cleaner, OHHHHH Yeeeaaah!!
Bolt on upgrade, fully reverseable... ::) ::) ::)