My Willys 3A and 3B Community
3A, 3B, DJ Technical Knowledge Base => "Original"-- Technical Questions, Answers, Observations => Topic started by: Jeff_M on September 15, 2013, 10:01:16 PM
-
Ryan M (my son) graciously trailered his Jeep down here yesterday and we spent the day bombing around.� What a blast.� It's unbelievable how well that thing drives.� However, I'm thinking it doesn't have as much power as it should.� My first car was a '68 VW beetle with 52 hp and a 4 speed, and it sure didn't slow down in the hills like this 3A does (which, by virtue of its overdrive, also has a four speed).� �It is pretty comfortable at 50 mph, but when you start up a grade, it slows down fast...downshifting is often needed.� It uses very little if any oil, and doesn't smoke; Ryan says it has pretty good compression, although I don't know the numbers.� It does run very well.� I don't believe the Jeep weighs much more than the VW did.�
The problem is, this is the only 3A I've driven out on the highway; I have none others to compare it to.� Are my expectations too high?
-
Jeff,
Good question.� I had similar complaints, but no other Willys to compare to...until the Fall Colors Tour last year.
My Willys was just off a fresh rebuild.� Driving it around the neighborhood, it seemed to run well, but I learned early on to avoid steep hills and long steady inclines.� I just figured this was what a 60 hp engine was going to give me.
Fast forward to the FCT 2013...
Other Willys Jeeps were climbing up my rear end as if I were standing still.� It was a little embarrassing.� I convinced myself that I was running heavier than the other Willys.� After all, I had my wife, two dogs, a cooler full of stuff, tons of tools, and a bunch of jeeps parts, just in case of failure.
It still bothered me though.� When I got home from that trip, I set off to find the real reason for my lack of power.� I axed the Solex carb after rebuilding my Carter.� At the same time, I decided to learn about timing.� I discovered my distributor was at a limit when I went to turn it to dial in the timing.� The PO had it close enough to run good, but not good enough to run great.� I was forced to re-index my oil pump so I could adjust the timing correctly.� That was a pain, but it was worth it.
Also, my timing chain (old GPW L-134) was very sloppy.� I replaced it too.
After dialing in the timing, setting up my Carter carb, and new timing chain, it was time to take it for a spin.� I was shocked over the increase in power.� I went looking for hills and inclines I had avoided before.� No more down shifting required where I often worried I wasn't going to make it up.
Needless to say, I am looking forward to the FCT this year.
Here's the only problem...I'm not sure if the timing adjustments, the timing chain, or the Carter carb were responsible for my power increase.� I did them all at the same time.� It could have been one of these three, or a combination of two or more.� I'm most inclined to believe my timing was the culprit, but I'm not positive.� I may never know, but I really don't need to.� I now have a Willys that has all the power it needs considering the 9" brakes and archaic steering system. ;)
I rambled on...and probably didn't help you at all.
Tim
-
Very helpful Tim. I'm thinking all three components you mentioned could use attention on my Willys. I have only adjusted the timing by ear and feel - no precise measuring of any sort.
I've never had the timing chain cover off so I'm not sure what's going on under there. I suspect it is gear driven - no chain - but I should probably still take a look.
I have never really disassembled the Carter. It has been removed for cleaning etc but never dissected or rebuilt.
Geez...and I was wondering what I was going to do all winter now that my jeep was "finished".
-
. . . now that my jeep was "finished".
It's NEVER finished.
;D ;D ;D
-
I have often wondered the same thing in regards to power. On my 3a, I rebuilt the motor and the Carter carb and set my timing with a light (several times). On a flat grade, I can chug along at 45-50 without much trouble. However, when I start up an incline it does slow down and pull pretty hard to get up it. While I would love to have an overdrive, I really don't think I would get to use it that much because it is mostly hills where I live. I have wondered if I have everything dialed in exact enough, at the time I was entralled that it actually worked. Not long after I rebuilt my carb myself, Carl started a thread on rebuilding his carb and I realized I didn't even come CLOSE to the precision he did. He was like a surgeon with a scapel....and I was using a butter knife.
In the end, on a stock system we are still dealing with a 60 hp flat head 4 cylinder on a 6 volt system. ;) Leaving everything completely stock will have some serious limits.
At the Midwest Fall Reunion, I was parked next to another 51 3a that belonged to a mechanic. While he still had the L134 motor installed, he had did a port and polish on the valves, bored it .020 over, coverted it to 12 volt, relocated the oil filter, installed a paper air cleaner and was running an electronic ignition. He took me for a ride and let me tell you.....that combo made for a fun little ride!
-
I drove about forty miles and had my foot in the bucket most of the time, although I usually didn't exceed fifty.� I was told not to downshift the overdrive unless I was stopped, so often I had to wait quite a while before down shifting as I was actually downshiftng two gears.� It would slow to thirty, but never ran hot...faithfully showed 190 degrees even at the crest of a hill.� Seems to me if the timing were off it might begin to overheat especially when lugging...but I'm hardly a mechanic.�
In another, totally unrelated point, I did learn about the "Jeep Wave." ;)
-
Hi Ryan,
� My timing marks are on the flywheel hiding behind a little peep hole.� Almost impossible to use a timing light.�
I used Sean's Geico timing method listed at the 2A under the FAQ section.� It makes timing a Willys almost enjoyable.
Unless your engine has been bubba 'd, a fairly quick way to determine if you have a chain drive or gear drive is to look at the timing cover.� Take a look at the photo below.� Check out my timing cover.� See the horizontal rib and the button in the center of the circular raised area?� If your timing cover has this, it is likely a chain drive.� If it does not, its a gear drive.
(http://i1195.photobucket.com/albums/aa397/athawk11/20110725016_zps35e78353.jpg) (http://s1195.photobucket.com/user/athawk11/media/20110725016_zps35e78353.jpg.html)
-
Thanks for the info Tim. Your post has hopefully reduced future burden on you as it's inevitable I would post a "How the Hell Do I Time my Motor" question. I'll take a closer read through the GEICO method and see if I can make some sense of it. I know my flywheel has been resurfaced so presumably the timing marks are gone. I'm hoping there's a reasonable work-around for that. My timing cover has a vertical rib so probably gear drive.
BTW, have fun on the FCT. I've been checking the 2A thread for new pics and updates roughly every 17 seconds this week.
-
The timing marks are on the front/engine side of the flywheel, so they should still be there, visible through that little porthole below the starter. You will need to have #1 close to TDC to find them...
My timing cover also has the vertical rib and it is definitely gear drive..
-
Thanks Ryan!
Haines Garage will be here tomorrow. He and I will head to the Thirsty Dirt on Thursday morning. My wife will follow on Friday, so HG and I will have one manly man day to tear it up. Should be a real kick in the pants!!! Would love to get more of my 3A bretheren out here for future FCT events. Just think of it...up to a full week of trail rides, Willys Jeeps, and some of the most brilliant Willys minds on the face of the planet...all in one place. Everyone should make this a bucket list item!! 8-)
Tim
-
I would certainly love to make my way over from Utah, but am unable to. Please post some pics to let the rest of us see what we missed.
-
Yes, I would agree with what has been said about really taking the time to dial in the timing and ignition system. Can't say for sure about older engines as mine is a later Supersonic model, but the jeep sure gets out of the hole as fast as you can shift it. Big hills are OK if you shift to what you want first, shifting midway and loosing steam seems to be a tough to recover from. Unrelated to jeeps, but I recently did all new ignition on my '79 toyota 4 cyl. and it gained tons of power and something like 8 mpg. I thought it was just a dog all summer long. Would have done a better setup had I known...
-Jesse
-
So I headed out to the garage tonight armed with 17 printed pages of GEICO timing literature. As expected, I'm stuck already. I cannot find any timing marks on the flywheel. I went around twice just to make sure. I did find these number though. I think they read "641955". Any idea what they are?
And the bigger question- How can I properly time my Jeep without timing marks? Short of replacing the flywheel with a correctly marked one is there a way around it?
For what it's worth, I had to mess with the distributor to get it running during my rebuild. The #1 plug wire goes approx at the 11 o'clock position on the distributor cap. I didn't notice this when I originally ripped everything apart so I had a hell of a time getting it going as I was trying to hook everything up to factory spec. Presumably the oil pump was installed improperly at some point (prior to me). Carl Walck has a fantastic video on how to troubleshoot and remedy that problem and I was able to get it going within a few minutes after watching it. That was 3200 miles ago.
-
Something is odd there as you should be able to see the entire opening in the engine plate, your's appears to be partially covered by the block casting. Just off the top of my head I'd say that your rear engine plate is for a different year engine.
If you can find absolute TDC on #1 , you could mark your flywheel, then turn it back 5 degrees and you would have a starting place...
Others more knowledgeable in trouble shooting this will have answers..
You can see the timing hole in my engine..
-
Check out the part number on the Walck ring gear...
http://walcks4wd.com/ring-gear-flywheel-124-tooth.html
Does your front pulley happen to have a TDC notch in it around the perimeter? Mine did....I'm not sure why...
-
Check out the part number on the Walck ring gear...
http://walcks4wd.com/ring-gear-flywheel-124-tooth.html
Does your front pulley happen to have a notch in it around the perimeter? Mine did....I'm not sure why...
LOL...I was just coming back to edit my post and speculate that "641955" was a part number and that the flywheel is probably on backwards. Good eyes.
My motor is not original to the Jeep. It was an alleged "new in crate" replacement as found at some surplus supplier in NY back in the late '80's / early '90's.
Not sure if I have a notch on the pulley. I may not be able to check until tomorrow.
-
That is just the ring gear, which is a press fit ...
i think the bigger issue is the partial covering of your timing hole...
Now, if you could get a good flashlight and a mirror, and if you were to screw your head on backwards, you might just be able to see the marks through that tiny gap between the casting and the rear plate....!
-
I was not able to screw my head on backwards (although my wife you tell you it always is) but I do have a notch on the pulley. Here's an old pic of my motor. Can I work with the notch instead of the timing marks on the flywheel?
-
I would say that you could only really get in the ball park...In the picture of my engine the mark is at TDC..but there is no mark for you to align your notch with, so you would just have to eyeball it, which might help you find the flywheel marks...the timing mark/pointer that I have is from an M-38, and I altered it so it could be used....
Even if you can't unscrew your head. I'd make an effort to look in that timing hole, between the flywheel and the engine case, and see if you can't find the timing marks...they would be just inboard of the seam between the ring gear and the flywheel....but the more I look at your picture the less likely that seems...
Do you have a timing light?
you could buy an M-38 timing index and go from there. not 100% accurate but better than nothing!
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Jeep-Willys-M38-M38A1-M170-Crankshaft-Pulley-Timing-Pointer-NOS-G740-G758-/171062588793?pt=Vintage_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&hash=item27d41ff579
-
I'm thinking if I can locate TDC on the #1 piston with the use of a pressure gauge I can mark the corresponding location of the notch on the timing cover. From that point I could figure and mark 5 deg BTC and go from there. Does that make sense? I've never really timed anything so this is all new.
-
You won't be able to find TDC with a pressure guage. You will have to do the bent wire fishing trick to find the top of the piston travel or drop the pan and look up, or off with the head.
-
Yes, as Bretto said, I think you will have to feel for it....and even at that there will be a small amount of crank rotation that will result in little or no vertical piston movement, when it's right at the top....but you can average it and find center, and you will get very close...and with that mark on the crank pulley you should be able to find it without too much trouble..
Then check your flywheel, and scribe a mark if you can...or maybe if you are lucky one of those numerals in the part number will line up!
But, it runs now, right?
If you were to put a continuity-tester across your points, and rotate the engine until the rotor is pointing at #1 wire position, and when the points break, then you will know where the present setting is.....unhook the battery though, you are just looking for continuity....then compare that with all your various marks, and maybe even the wire-feel test..
-
Does anyone else have this raised rib on their timing cover? It may be coincidence but it lines up VERY closely with TDC. I messed around with Bretto's bent wire suggestion for a little bit tonight. I didn't spend enough time to get TDC pinned down exactly but close enough to know this rib is on or very near it relative to the notch on the pulley. I'm curious if there are other marks near this rib that may be hidden beneath the paint or exactly what this rib identifies. TDC? IGN? Neither?
-
I've read something about timing covers with timing marks...let me see if I can dredge it up...that really looks close....
you might scrape off some of the surrounding paint and see what you find....
-
With the pulley mark set opposite that ridge, where is the rotor and are the points open? Can you get the notch and ridge to line up when the rotor is pointing to #1?
-
With the pulley mark set opposite that ridge, where is the rotor and are the points open?� Can you get the notch and ridge to line up when the rotor is pointing to #1?
Yes, when the notch and ridge are lined up the rotor points to #1 as it should. I can adjust the points to open or close by rotating the distributor but I'm not sure where on that ridge I should be so if I'm off there everything else is off too. I think I left it roughly in the middle of the ridge. I just found this on the 3B site which makes sense:
"If the bottom pulley was a clock, you'll find the engine cover marks at about the 11:00 position. Sometimes it is a little bulge in the front engine cover, with the left side of the bulge 5 degrees before TDC, and the right side of the bulge at TDC."
-
I found this thread..
http://www.thecj2apage.com/forums/tuning-the-47-53_topic12700_post105900.html?KW=timing+marks#105900
And this picture is posted somewhere in it...
-
If you don't have the marks I'd go with the bulge...you may have a later 3b f-head timing cover....
Do you have a timing light?
My timing cover was replaced when we rebuilt the engine as the cup that held the seal had come loose...the machinist "found one in the back" so i have no idea where mine came from....
-
Do you have a timing light?
No, but I didn't have half my current *rear end of tools prior to owning this Jeep. Might as add a timing light to the mix. I'll pick one up this week.
-
If you can find a 6v one that would be perfect...but a 12v light will work, but you need a 12v battery to make it work. I used one of those rechargeable jumper batteries.
If i remember right the light needed to have a common ground with the spark plug sensor and the 12v battery, so I grounded the 12v to the frame, along with the negative cable on the timing light, and then just hooked the positive side of the light to the 12v battery positive terminal. but I have a pretty old timing light....
-
Sorry I'm late chiming in here, but that bulge on Ryan's timing cover is the timing mark used to set the timing on the motor. I have one just like it on my motor. Just like someone else posted, the left side of the bulge is 5 degrees BTDC and the right side of the mark is TDC.
Do yourself a favor right now and get a bit of white paint and mark both the notch and the timing mark on the cover. It will save you a lot of headache when you are staring down in the darkness with a timing light.
About the timing light....get one. I have an old light that my Dad bought at Sears YEARS ago. Not sure if it is 12volt or 6volt, but when I use it on my 6volt system it is not as bright and I have to turn the lights off in the shop in order to see the flash.......but it always works.
Good Luck!
-
Something is odd there as you should be able to see the entire opening in the engine plate, your's appears to be partially covered by the block casting. Just off the top of my head I'd say that your rear engine plate is for a different year engine.
For the production of the M-38, the engine block cast was changed.� It had a larger flange that would cover a portion of the timing hole.� Ryan has a late engine casting.� This was around the same time that they added the timing notches to the front of the engine.
Here is a pretty good discussion about this at the 2A...
http://www.thecj2apage.com/forums/whats-the-deal-with-my-timing-window_topic21461.html
-
Well, there you go!
All questions answered....!
-
Excellent info. Thanks to all. Let me see if I can scrounge up a timing light and make a mess with some white paint.
-
I picked up a timing light today. It's a battery operated one which wouldn't have been my first choice but it's the only one I could find in town and even it had a heavy layer of dust on it. My guess is pretty soon we'll only be able to find timing lights in antique shops. Turns out the battery-only feature is pretty handy for quick roadside timing checks. Hook the one clamp to the #1 plug wire and you're ready to go. Pretty slick.
Anyways, I really spent some time setting the points and finding what I think it TDC on the pulley and painting corresponding marks on the timing cover. The bulge on the timing cover is hard to read. If the left side of the bulge is indeed IGN then something is wrong. My motor will barely idle and definitely isn't right. If I advance another 5(??) degrees it settles in very nicely, which is where I ultimately left it. If I am indeed advanced to 10 degrees, is that an indication of compensating for something else that's failing?
I have a "test" hill that I've been using to determine changes in performance. Prior to this thread I know I would reach roughly 50mph through the gently downward straight just before climbing the hill. By the time I crest the hill, I'd be down to 30mph. This is all in OD 3rd. I could downshift but the end result really isn't any better than just slogging through it in high gear.
With my freshly tweaked timing I now hit 58-60mph through the straight and crest the hill at blazing 42 mph!!!! That's a pretty significant difference and I am extremely pleased with the result.� It feels a lot peppier at slower speeds too.
All of this testing still involved a fair amount of trial and error - several sets of points, new rotor, new condenser, back to old condenser etc. At one time during my "roadside adjustments" I managed to * things up so bad I had to take a charity tow back to my house -� Good thing I have at least one friendly neighbor with pick-up truck who travels home from work at roughly the same time I idiotically disable my own vehicle. Never a dull moment.
I did spend a good amount of effort earlier this year after my initial rebuild adjusting timing by "feel". I think I had it pretty good at one time but it so gradually fell out of time I didn't really notice it. I'll be paying closer attention to it now. I have a pretty long drive over some serious hills this weekend so I'll see how it holds up.
I'm still curious about the possibility of having the timing too advanced. Any input on that? And is there an easy way to gauge RPM's on these Jeeps? I'm curious to know what my idle engine speed is as I'm adjusting the timing.
-
Did you use a dwell meter to set your points? Setting the gap with a feeler will get you close but you need to check the dwell to make sure you are getting the max out of your coil.
-
[Anyways, I really spent some time setting the points and finding what I think it TDC on the pulley and painting corresponding marks on the timing cover. The bulge on the timing cover is hard to read. If the left side of the bulge is indeed IGN then something is wrong. My motor will barely idle and definitely isn't right. If I advance another 5(??) degrees it settles in very nicely, which is where I ultimately left it. If I am indeed advanced to 10 degrees, is that an indication of compensating for something else that's failing? [/quote]
Ryan, the left side of the bulge is 5 degrees BTDC, not top dead center. If you get the timing advanced too much, you should be hearing detonation (spark ping) in the motor when you get in the higher RPMs. If the engine won't idle, you may have your idle screw set too low on the carb.
-
Ryan, the left side of the bulge is 5 degrees BTDC, not top dead center.� If you get the timing advanced too much, you should be hearing detonation (spark ping) in the motor when you get in the higher RPMs.� If the engine won't idle, you may have your idle screw set too low on the carb.
Yep got it. I said the left side of the bulge is "IGN" which on some flywheels is equal to 5 degrees BTDC.....just easier to type. I'm probably another 5 degrees beyond that now. I did mess with the idle screw too and it didn't seem to help.
Did you use a dwell meter to set your points?� Setting the gap with a feeler will get you close but you need to check the dwell to make sure you are getting the max out of your coil.
I used a feeler gauge to set the points (.020"). I have no idea about using a swell meter.....yet another variable to chase down.....
-
I bought a tester at Sears long ago..it had a tach, dwell and who knows what else...and you could set it for four cylinder engines...of course 4 bangers are pretty common..it's the 6v that messes things up...maybe a shop that specializes in old Volkswagens?
-
Dwell meter measures the amount of time (in degrees of rotation) that your points are closed.� Will give you much better results than setting the gap.� Just hook it up to the coil - and ground.� I have the $30 from Amazon, works fine with my 6V tractor.� Also works as a tachometer which is helpful in setting the idle.� Must have tool for working on a points ignition engine.� Oh yeah you need to set the dwell before you set the timing, because changing the dwell will change the timing.
Here is a nice thread from our friends on the CJ2A Forum: http://www.thecj2apage.com/forums/timing-light_topic8053.html
-
The forum members here never stop amazing me. Earlier this week I received an e-mail from our friend 1955CJ-5 (Randy) that suggested I take a look at the throttle linkage attached to my carb. What he had discovered on his 3A is that when the accelerator pedal was pushed to the floor the butterfly in the carb was only about 2/3rds open.� I checked mine and, sure enough, same deal. It occurred to me that I had installed a new rubber boot on the accelerator pedal shaft during the rebuild. Prior to my rebuild there was no boot. Even if the PO had adjusted the carb linkage correctly at the time, the fact that I added the rubber boot would screw up the adjustment because the pedal no longer comes close to hitting the floor. As I did in many places during my rebuild, I think I just unbolted what was there, cleaned it up, and bolted it back together without it even occurring to me that adjustments needed to be made. Rookie mistakes.
Anyways, tonight I installed a newly rebuilt carb from Scoutpilot (another saga, but I can assure you his carbs are great and his service after the sale is outstanding). With the new carb installed I adjusted the throttle linkage properly. Since it was pitch black and 25 degrees out, I figured it was perfect weather for a topless Jeep voyage. I bundled up and headed out to my test road and up the test hill. What a difference. Even before I reached the hill I noticed a significant increase in acceleration from a dead stop. I hit the 60 mph mark WELL before the end of the straightaway and barrelled up the hill no slower than 46mph. I made three passes and all were within a couple miles of each other. Slower speed climbs up other hills were noticeably better at holding a steady speed too. Good stuff. Yes, I was running with a new carb but I really don't think my previous carb was all that bad, it has simply found a new home on my decrepit M38.
I need to continue fine tuning the throttle linkage and carb idle adjustments and I'd like to get my hands on a dwell meter and figure that out as well. It was just too cold for me to do much more testing tonight but I'm thrilled with the progress at this point.
When Jeff_M started this thread I was barely hitting 50mph after the straightaway and was down to 30mph at the peak of the hill. Timing was also at 10-15 deg BTDC and when I set the timing again tonight I set it at 5 deg BTDC - right where it is supposed to be. That's quite an improvement.
-
That's a significant improvement.� Funny how a simple adjustment can make such a difference, although in your case you've done a lot more than that.
I'll try to refrain from any posts for a while so you can get your sleep and save your money.� :-)
BTW, how do the vintage 6v headlights work in the dark?
-
I have no complaints with the 62 year old 6v bulbs. The brand new high beam switch, however, failed when stomped on which can be a little alarming when all goes dark at 50+mph.
-
Ryan, I'm glad all those changes have improved your performance.
All those changes, timing, new carb, new distributor and the linkage set-up have contributed.
But really, 60 mph? At night? In an old jeep?
I wish mine would go 60.... :(
I better set my sights on an overdrive.....
-
After a losing battle with my rebuilt carb, Scoutpilot (whose customer service has been second to none...anywhere), shipped me another carb. With it bolted on and the timing adjusted I headed out to the "test hill" for another run. Previous top speed on the straightaway leading up to the hill was just about 60mph. This time I was just under the 65mph mark and still accelerating when I chickened out and let up. I rocketed up the hill and for a split second dipped a hair below 50mph but by the time I crested the top of the hill I was holding a steady 52mph.
So the performance continues to improve by leaps and bounds since the beginning of this thread. I started at 50mph on the straightaway and can now most certainly hit 65mph. My "hillcrest" speed of 30mph has improved to 52mph. Pretty impressive percentage improvements. It just shows how obvious it is that because you simply bolted your Jeep back together does not mean it's running at peak performance. Minor tweaking to make it right can really pay huge dividends or keep you lagging severely behind if you choose not to address it.
-
I can't wait to drive it again....and see what else I can find wrong with it...not.