My Willys 3A and 3B Community
3A, 3B, DJ Technical Knowledge Base => "Original"-- Technical Questions, Answers, Observations => Topic started by: athawk11 on October 12, 2013, 09:50:03 AM
-
Has anyone used the reproduction leaf springs being produced by MD Juan or other after market producers?
I'm in the market. And money in always an object. I've looked at the Walcks reproductions, but a new set will run nearly $600.00.
A $600.00 set of springs on a $1,000.00 Willys doesn't make a lot of sense to me.
Tim
-
Oh but then you will have a $1600 Willys!
I've used both Walcks and Kaiser-Willys. The KW seem a little stiffer for the same leaf count, as each leaf looks a little thicker though I haven't measured them. K-W has the military loop, Walcks did not just over a year ago when I bought mine.
I tried the local spring shop. Prices were about the same but i would have needed to take the jeep down for them to fit the springs....so I would have had labor charges...
I also talked with these folks. Very knowledgeable and helpful but shipping was a killer....
http://www.generalspringkc.com/Leaf_Springs_s/1817.htm
-
I'm on the same shopping trip. I don't want to dump $600 into springs for my rattletrap M38 so I've been looking at some alternatives. The OMIX-ADA springs are reasonably priced ($65 +/-) but if they are complete junk it isn't much of a bargain. Has anyone else here used OMIX-ADA springs long enough to know whether or not they hold up?
-
Ryan,
I guess that's really what I'm asking. This Willys will probably leave pavement once a year, if that. I really don't need a spring that will hold up for another 60+ years. But if the Omix product sags after six months of use, I'm probably going to be a little mad at myself.
I might post the same question at the 2A. Maybe someone over there has been our ginny-pig. ;D
Tim
-
For what it's worth, I put new rear springs on my 3B 4 years ago. Got them from Walck's.
They are REALLY stiff. Rides like an empty dump truck.
Put 800 lbs in the back and the ride smooths out nicely.
I assume you know that the Willys, from day one in the military, was called a 1/4 ton vehicle but had a rated payload of about 1,000 lbs. The math tells me that's a half ton.
So
If you get springs that are even close to factory spec, you'll have much stiffer springs than you probably want.
Check with Alcan Spring
www.alcanspring.com
They will make springs for the payload and ride that you want. They have much experience with old Jeeps. I wish I had done that. They weren't that much more expensive.
-
That's interesting John. Thank you. I guess I would want the springs just stiff enough that the tire won't rub the inside of the wheel well during axle articulation. Yet soft enough to enjoy a cruise. Not sure how to arrive at this without giving a few different springs a try. Or getting the more experienced Willys folks, like you, to chime in.
Tim
-
For the CJ-5, I put ten leaf packs on the front and nine leaf packs on the rear....all from Walck's....I like the ride..
Now it had 13 leaf fronts and 13 rear originally, so it used to be really stiff...
-
Hi Randy,
I think the 10 front, 9 rear is the stock configuration for a 3A. I'm guessing that the CJ5 is heavier than a 3A, but not much.
What do you have on your current project?
Tim
-
I think it's:
For a CJ3A
Standard (stock) leaf is 8 at the front and 9 at the rear.
The heavy duty option was 10 at the front and 11 at the rear.
will check tonight in the part manual
-
Hi Randy,
I think the 10 front, 9 rear is the stock configuration for a 3A.� I'm guessing that the CJ5 is heavier than a 3A, but not much.� �
What do you have on your current project?
Tim
I went with the same leaf count, 10 front and 9 rear, but they are Kaiser-Willys, (actually Crown Automotive) springs and they feel a bit stiffer than the Walck's springs. But without the body mounted it tough to tell....
The original packs I took off the 3a were 10 front and 9 rear....
The parts book shows 10 front and 9 rear as standard, and 10 front 11 rear as heavy duty. It also lists the lengths of the separate leaves, which will affect stiffness.....
-
Ok, I checked.
In my Part list book models CJ-2A and CJ-3A third edition 1949
Page 98
Group 27-01 Front spring
front spring assembly part # A-612 is 8 leaves
Group 27-01A Front spring Heavy duty
front spring assembly part # A-8463 is 10 leaves
Group 27-02 Rear spring
rear spring assembly part # A-614 is 9 leaves
Group 27-02A Rear spring Heavy duty
rear spring assembly part # A-15728 is 11 leaves
Heavy duty option is after serial # 169923
-
Interesting.
The stock springs on the 3B were 10 front and 9 rear.
So the heavy duty fronts from the 3A became the standard for the 3B. Extra weight of the F-head engine? Who knows?
-
That's interesting I guess I would want the springs just stiff enough that the tire won't rub the inside of the wheel well during axle articulation.� Yet soft enough to enjoy a cruise.� Not sure how to arrive at this ...
That's where Alcan comes in. They will ask you what payload capacity you'll want for your rear springs. They'll even ask you if you'll be mounting a spare tire on the rear - that's an extra 40 lbs or so.
So you tell them you have a spare tire, a back seat and two small adults as rear seat passengers (or whatever you envision) as your maximum anticipated load and they'll take it from there.
Yes there's still some guesswork involved, but you'll come much closer than just randomly buying some "OEM reproduction" springs from a vendor.
And remember, when a CJ was new, it did ride like a truck. Willys assumed you'd put a half ton of stuff in the back. That's what it was designed for.
But they still rode like a truck. The harsh ride of the Jeep in WWII caused a condition known as "Jeep Seat".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilonidal_cyst
Relevant quote from that article:
"The condition was widespread in the United States Army during World War II. More than eighty thousand soldiers having the condition required hospitalization; [12] the average length of these wartime hospital stays was 55 days.[13] The condition was termed "jeep seat" or "Jeep riders' disease", because a large portion of people who were being hospitalized for it rode in Jeeps, and prolonged rides in the bumpy vehicles were believed to have caused the condition due to irritation and pressure on the coccyx."
More than you ever wanted to know.
;D ;D ;D
-
I'm putting new leaf springs on the front. They are OMIX-ADA. The one challenge I found (too late to return) was that the front curl for the shackle brackets had bushings installed. These were too small for the shackles to fit. The rear curl also has a bushing and the rear pin fits like a glove.
I guess I'm going to have to drill out the front bushings so the shackles will fit. Anyone else run into this?
-
Yes you can drive those bushings out...find a socket with an OD that fits well and support the spring so the bushing has someplace to go...One came out pretty easily for me and the other was tough. The socket looks kinda beat up but I didn't have an alternative tool.
-
I bought the Omix Ada springs for the front of mine, drove out the bushing and have been pretty happy with them. For the back I bought a recurve kit from 4 wheel drive parts. It's a heavy short spring that fits on the bottom of the spring pack. I had to pull two springs to get them on. But it pushes the spring pack back into the right curvature and seems to eliminate the jeep list. I've been happy with them, nice enough ride and fair enough load capacity.
-
I was just flipping back through some rebuild pics and I stumbled across my springs fresh out of the box - turns out they are OMIX-ADA afterall! I bought them from Kaiserwillys but they can be had MUCH cheaper from other sources. I'm running 9 leaf on the rear and 8 on the front. If they have sagged it's been very slight. I have nearly 2 years (1 year actually running) with these springs and nearly 3500 miles. No issues yet.
-
I got mine from KW as well - Omix Ada - I had a $25.00 credit at KW and then they had a 10% discount with free freight. Total 4 springs (9 & 10 leaf) around $425
Check out tech talk - they are a bear to install the U shackles on the rear for some reason. Non of mine had the bushings installed. With no weight on the front end the 10 leaf springs feel solid.
-
So all this talk about driving out end bushings and such has me confused.
I bought my springs from Walk's and simply bolted them in place.
Is this another case of KW parts not being quite what they ought to be?
Carl told me his springs were US made.
I've bought several parts from KW and even more from Walk's.
My experience with KW has been that you need to know more than they do which, in my case, isn't that big a problem.
With Carl Walk, on the other hand, he knows WAY more than I'll ever know and he's been dead-on correct every time I've had a question.
KW are nice people and their prices and service are good, but they simply are NOT as knowledgeable as Carl. Put him together with Herm the Overdrive Guy and you may well have all that is possible to be known about old Willys.
-
My OMIX springs as purchased from KW were not that difficult to replace. They were one of the first things I did and being ultra-green at this stuff at the time any problem would have been a huge challenge. As far as I remember they just bolted right up.
-
So all this talk about driving out end bushings and such has me confused.
I bought my springs from Walk's and simply bolted them in place.
Is this another case of KW parts not being quite what they ought to be?
Carl told me his springs were US made.
I've bought several parts from KW and even more from Walk's.
My experience with KW has been that you need to know more than they do which, in my case, isn't that big a problem.
With Carl Walk, on the other hand, he knows WAY more than I'll ever know and he's been dead-on correct every time I've had a question.
KW are nice people and their prices and service are good, but they simply are NOT as knowledgeable as Carl. Put him together with Herm the Overdrive Guy and you may well have all that is possible to be known about old Willys.
I agree 100%...
I put a set of four Walck's spring packs on my CJ-5. They went on fine and work great.
The set of four spring packs on the 3A were from Kaiser-Willys in their "Master rebuilt" suspension kit. Crown automotive springs...really difficult to install the U bolt shackles and pretty stiff.
KW may source their springs from different suppliers depending on where you live. With free shipping offered it's in their interest to find the nearest supplier. Mine came from Reno/Sparks Nevada, about 400 miles away...