My Willys 3A and 3B Community
3A, 3B, DJ Technical Knowledge Base => "Original"-- Technical Questions, Answers, Observations => Topic started by: stony on July 23, 2013, 01:47:03 AM
-
Well this is the first step in my CJ3A preservation project. Repairing the temperature gauge. My late brother in law was apparently trying to "fix" my jeep and in what I think was an attempt to remove the engine unscrewed the temperature gauge and twisted off the capillarity tube. This thread will document my attempt to get it working again. Plans are fairly simple: Remove and clean up the brass reservoir, reattach the capillary tube, refill it with ether and reseal it, cross my fingers and hope it is reasonably accurate. Cosmetically will just repaint the rim around the gauge to keep it from rusting any more.
OK here is what I am starting with. Fairly decent looking gauge, but the capillary is twisted off at the top of the reservoir, and you can see that it is held solidly in the head fitting by rust. Going to have to clean out the rust and remove the brass reservoir.
-
The first step was to remove the rust holding the reservoir.� A no. 4/0 worm hook did a fairly good job then I found an old cork borer that fit over the brass perfectly.� Ground the bevel off and filed some teeth in the edge and by rotating it back and forth was able to remove all of the rust in direct contact with the brass.� Soaking in penetrating oil and using my vice as a press was able to get the reservoir out.� Only took 2 hours.� Once the reservoir was out it was polished a little and the rest of the rust was removed from the head fitting with a small stone in my Dremel tool.� So here is where we are.� Need to drill out the the old tube, and solder in the capillary tube, should only lose about 1/4 inch.� My original plan was to put a drop of solder on the reservoir and drill through it and the brass to refill, then quickly hit the solder with an iron to seal it, and it looks like that is how it was originally done, so this may work after all.
-
I repaired an original gauge that had broke like that. I made a thread on the 2a page about it. I'll see if I can find it.
-
http://www.thecj2apage.com/forums/fixing-original-temp-gauges_topic23832_post207933.html?KW=Temperature+gauge+repair#207933
-
Great thread....I too have one that needs repair....
-
Nice work! I have seen a couple of different threads where the gauge was repaired by grafting the parts from a new gauge onto the old one. I am taking a slightly different tack with the goal of repairing the original one using all of the original parts. Next step will be drilling out the remnants of the old tube and reattaching the capillary tube.
-
Step by step, problem by problem.� I am pretty certain that I can just insert the capillary tube back into the reservoir and solder it.� However since the flair on the end of the tube is crimped on to the support wire (solidly) not enough of the tube was exposed to do what is needed.� So put it in my vice and gave it a gentle squeeze perpendicularly to the crimp to make it round again.� Worked perfectly and was able to just screw the flair out of the way exposing the tube.� Should be plenty to do the job.� Had it been too short could just cut the wire back a little.� Anyway so far so good ;)�
-
I'm curious to see how you will refill it with the correct amount ether and seal it up without it all leaking out.
-
Yeah me too LOL!� OK, so time to drill it out.� Drilled a hole in a block of wood to hold the brass so I could hold it vertically.� Wanted to set it up so that I could hold it with my fingers so if the bit caught in the soft copper I could let it slip without breaking the bit.� Started with 5/64" and drilled, thought it would go through pretty quickly, figured about 1/4 inch, but was still cutting copper at 3/8 so I stopped, good enough.� Used a piece of 0.024 wire from my welder to make sure the hole was clear all the way through.� �Followed the 5/64 with a 3/32 drill to a depth of about 1/8 inch to try to assure a better solder seal.� �Needed a little more tubing exposed so cut off about 2 1/2 turns of support wire with the Dremel.� �Soldered it.� Doesn't look too bad and flair snugged up to the tube quite nicely.� The next thing was to remove the solder from the other end to see what is there.� Looks like there is a plug in the middle and solder was applied over it after the tube was filled.� �Not exactly sure what i am going to do for a fill hole, but might drill and tap for a small brass machine screw, fill with ether and solder, or maybe just JB Weld.� The amount of ether should not be too critical as long as there is enough so that some stays in the liquid state at 212 F.� Should create about 100 PSI at that temp. So far so good!
-
So, let's speculate...
How do you suppose they did it at the factory?
You could heat the bulb, immerse the gauge end of the tube into ether, then immerse the bulb in dry ice or something, to draw the ether in...but I know the gauge end is still attached...
Can you just pour ether? Better wear a gas mask!
-
I do not know, but there is no way to fill it from the gauge end since the gauge would have been assembled before it was filled. Since the bezel is crimped on there is no way to get inside of the gauge. It looks like it was filled then a plug was pressed in. The pressure from pressing in the plug would have given the concave shape to the end. Once the plug was in looks like solder was added to seal the plug. I may drill through the plug and if it is thick enough tap it for a 4-40 machine screw, fill and solder. Need a higher wattage soldering iron though.
-
I know Nisonger Instrument in NY will rebuild these bulb/capillary gauges. I had one rebuilt for an MG years ago..I should go look at it and see if there is a clue...
-
So I found it....
Looks like the bottom was plugged and soldered just as you said....
-
I read somewhere that the bulbs were filled in a cold room and there was a bucket of molten solder next to the person so they could quickly dunk it in and seal it? Not sure how true this is though. If I didn't bookmark it, it wasn't important then.
-
I'll bet they just hit it with one of those big old industrial soldering irons, you know the ones with about 1/2 pound of iron on the end. They will do some serious melting. I think I can locate one. When I get the hole drilled will check it out with some compressed air. Looking at the vapor pressure of diethyl ether about 50# should take it halfway (~180).
-
You guys seem pretty professional and I'm impressed with the skill and attention to detail in this project. I'm sure you already know this, but just for safety's sake, keep in mind that diethyl ether is extremely flammable and can be explosive under certain conditions. Would hate to hear that all your work went up in flames! Again, I expect you already knew this and I am probably just adding unnecessary info here, but safety first, eh . . .
-
Thanks AZ, yeah already have my safety goggles and flame retardant suit ready.� Filling and soldering will be an outdoor job.� Drilled it this morning and it looks like there was a plug in there.� Looks thick enough to thread for a brass screw. Professional??? Nope, just stubborn old farmer who would rather fix than replace. The challenge is fun.
-
I love it! A fun thread to follow! Thanks!
-
Very cool effort here! I'm pretty sure mine has an electric gauge in it right now, but the original style is nice.
I think you'll have to be careful not to get any air in there with the ether. The presence of air will affect the phase behaviour of the ether, and you won't get the same pressure/temperature relationship. Meaning, the gauge won't read right. If it's just a small amount of air, the error may not be large, though.
You should check the calibration when you're done. Easiest way to do that is to put the sensor end in boiling water. Just remember that water boils at 212�F only at sea level--the actual temperature gets lower as you increase in altitude. Where I live, it's more like 208�F.
-Paul
-
Thanks guys.� The hole is drilled, and it does appear that there was a little plug there.� Interesting thing is the capillary tube appears to extend about 3/4 of an inch into the bulb.� I don't think the air will make much difference, because it is compressible and the vapor pressure of ether is so high the gauge should be reasonably accurate as long as some liquid ether remains in the bulb.� Ether should be here tomorrow and still have to find my heavy duty soldering iron.� As for calibration, since the back of the gauge is inaccessible because the bezel is crimped on, there is no way to access the Bourdon tube or linkage to adjust it, will have to live with whatever I get.� I'll be happy if it moves at all LOL.�
Update the diethyl ether just showed up. 500 ml was the minimum I could order, so will have enough left over to do approximately 99 more LOL. No puttin it off now.
-
I don't think the air will make much difference, because it is compressible and the vapor pressure of ether is so high the gauge should be reasonably accurate as long as some liquid ether remains in the bulb.� ...� As for calibration, since the back of the gauge is inaccessible because the bezel is crimped on, there is no way to access the Bourdon tube or linkage to adjust it, will have to live with whatever I get.
The air will not just be inert--it actually affects the pressure of the ether at a given temperature. The software I have that can do these calculations doesn't work for the diethyl ether - air mixture, so I can't tell you by how much. I entered a pentane-air mixture (pentane has a similar boiling point to diethyl ether), with 1% air by mass, to see what would happen, and for that mixture, it gave an error of about 3�F at 212�F (relative to the pure pentane). Not a big error, but perhaps noticeable.
Even though you can't change the calibration of the gauge, you can check how far off it is by putting it in boiling (or very hot) water with an accurate thermometer for comparison and then make a note of how far off it is.
-Paul
-
True for a gas mixture (Boyle's law right?), but the thermometer reading will depend on the vapor pressure of the liquid ether.� As the gas pressure inside the reservoir raises, the boiling point of the ether will rise, so at 212F the pressure is about 100 PSI.� So as long as there is liquid ether in there the pressure will rise as a function of the vapor pressure.� �Once the temperature has reached the point where all of the ether has boiled off the change in pressure will be a function of temperature on the expansion of a gas.� So if the boiling point of the ether continues to rise with increased pressure it shouldn't make any difference what the gas mixture above the ether is.� I think that is why ether was chosen, it's BP is 34C (about 100F) and it has a relatively high vapor pressure.� Of course I may be wrong, physical chemistry is a long way in the rearview mirror.
Update 2: Tried a couple of times tonight. No luck :( my plugs were not tight enough, and my wimpy soldering gun took too long to melt the solder. Things got too hot, built up too much pressure and the ether escaped. Have some other ideas, mostly unconventional LOL. Have to keep the ether cold and hit it quickly with a big soldering iron. One good thing I put some pressure on it from the air compressor, seems to work fine. Try again in a couple of days.
-
Just thinking out loud here, but could you drill a hole through a piece of dry ice and put the bulb through? That would leave the end open to solder but would keep the bulb and ether very cold. Still probably isn't going to work without a high temp iron though.
-Jesse
Don't mind the grade school illustration, you are getting what you pay for with this advice anyhow.
-
Thanks, yeah I have thought about that, problem is you would need a VERY hot iron to seal it, I have already thought about using epoxy, but it would never cure at low temp. I am leaning toward soldering in a copper capillary tube and filling through that and crimping it shut, then soldering or epoxying.
-
The gauges can be dis-assembled. The bezel ring is very soft steel. If I had thought to round the sharp edges on the screwdriver it would have been a smoother operation..as it is I marked the case a little, but not bad...
-
CJ, yeah I have taken them apart before, did not want to except as a last resort. I have some syringes coming so in theory I could fill it from the gauge end but would take forever. Beginning to think it was originally filled and sealed cold and the solder was added to strengthen the seal. Right now I am looking at two options: soldering in a small copper tube and crimping to seal or a small machine screw with a O ring to seal. Will reenforce with epoxy rather than solder. Anyway will figure something out ;). BTW my first jeep was a 56 CJ5 :)
-
My gauge was stuck right where the picture shows, so I figured that I might as well take it apart. I bent the Bourdon tube, and to my surprise it worked.....calibrated it with a candy thermometer and a coffee cup..
For that Bourdon tube to get bent/straightened to the point where the needle was pegged, the engine must have gotten pretty hot....
That old 55 CJ has been in the family since I was 8......
-
If you need to fasten a plug in a hurry, there is a product called 2P10 which is basically Crazy glue on steroids. Apply adhesive to the base and spray a shot of accelerator to the plug. When the two parts meet, you will have a high strength bond in about 3 seconds. Good luck, interesting thread.
Matt
-
Matt: That is a good idea, however CA glues are soluble in acetone, so I am pretty sure that they will not stand up to ether, which is an even better solvent. Right now I am leaning toward soldering on a brass 6-32 nut and using a machine screw and an "O" ring for a physical seal then overcoating with epoxy. I WILL make this thing work somehow! ;)
-
Stony,
When the gauges were new, would the entire capillary tube, Bourdon tube and bulb be filled with liquid ether?
Or would the bulb only be filled with liquid ether and the remainder ether vapor?
I suppose there needs to be room for vapor as that provides the pressure to expand the Bourdon tube...� I found a write-up on Bourdon tubes..interesting...
-
Putting a small copper tube on there is actually a pretty good idea, it would have a smaller area to heat when you need to solder it up. Now that bulb probably draws a lot of your heat away when you are trying to seal it with a standard iron.
-Jesse
-
If only I knew then what I know now, LOL.� OK so have been thinking about how to do this thing.� Went and got some heavy duty soldering stuff, and was trying to figure out how to keep things cold and hot at the same time.� Then said wait a minute, this should be something that anybody can do and do it cheaply, so scrapped the whole solder idea and did some research.� Changed tack to see how to seal the capsule without solder.� Figured that my bottle of ether came in a aluminum can with a plastic top, and a plastic seal, I needed to just make a gasket out of somwthing to seal with a screw.� Drilled and tapped the end of the brass reservoir for a 8-32 machine screw, smoothed and polished the area around the screw as best as I could.� Found out that Teflon is insoluble in ether.� Cool, got my roll of Teflon tape and took a look.� Didn't think it would seal on the threads, but might make a gasket with several layers.� Was looking for something a little thicker, then BINGO!� Teflon valve packing rope.� Perfect!!� Thought I would make a practice run, wrapped a piece tightly around a screw that I had cut down to about 1/4 inch long, and screwed it into the reservoir tight enough to deform the Teflon.� Cut off the tag ends with a razor blade and took a look.� It looked like a perfect gasket.� Why screw around, lets go for it!� Tossed the can of ether and the gauge in the freezer to cool down.� Pulled it out, filled my (just arrived from e-bay) blunt neeedle syringe with ether and filled the reservoir.� Screwed it down tight as I dared.� Let it sit for a minute or so and gave it the sniff test, could not smell any ether escaping.� Mixed up a batch of JB Weld for a final seal.� Will test it out tomorrow.� I am dying to see what will happen.� Photos are the screw and gasket, installed screw, and epoxied reservoir and blunt syringe I used to fill.� Anyway so far so good ;)
Update:� Came back after an hour and there was a tiny bubble in the JB, did not even break the surface.� Scraped the JB off and gave it another 1/8 turn, reapplied JB.� The gauge reads a little over 100 now, where before it was bottomed out.� This is going to work!
Update 2:� Another tiny bubble, cranked it down another tiny bit, another 1/2 hour looks good!� Let er set up.
Update 3: Dang! Another tiny leak. Think I know what went wrong. Should not have preformed gasket. Started over. Looks good, so far.
-
Think I got it :D!!
-
Great work and a very interesting read... Thanks Terry
-
Very nice!
Where did you buy the ether?
-
I bought the ether on e-bay.� Problem is that the smallest amount I could get was 500 ml, and that was $35, and $15 for shipping.� So payed a lot for the 15 ml or so that was actually used, but it was the challenge ;).� Anyway, looked at automotive starting fluid MSDS's (material safety data sheet) to see % diethyl ether and it was about 30% in the ones that I looked at, which was not enough (IMHO).� �Have since found this: http://www.greenpartstore.com/John-Deere-80-percent-Premium-Ether-Starting-Fluid-RE556468.html MSDS says 80% diethyl ether, 10-20% lpg.� That I believe would do it.� I believe that as long as there is liquid ether in the bulb the gauge should be reasonably accurate.� The lpg/ether mix may have some impact on the boiling point but it is probably not be enough to cause problems.� For $4 a can what the heck.
So this is what I wound up needing:
Various tools to clean out the rust.
Vice (or pliers) to uncrimp the flair.
Dremel tool to cut back the wire.
5/64 and 3/32 drills to drill for the tube. ($6)�
Soldering iron and solder to reattach the tube and remove solder from end of reservoir.
Couple of drills and taps, started with 6/32 wound up with 8/32
Blunt tip 3ml syringes from e-bay. ($7)
Teflon tape ($2) and valve packing ($3) (used 3/32 but would have used 1/16 if I could get it)
JB Weld ($5)
8/32 screw
Ether ($50) but the JD 80% is $4
So there it is, should be able to do it for about $15.� I don't see any reason why this should not keep on working for a long time.� Just need to clean up and paint the bezel.
-
I was under the the impression that these were filled with alcohol. At least that's what I put in one years ago and it still works today. I will never do that again.