My Willys 3A and 3B Community
3A, 3B, DJ Technical Knowledge Base => "Original"-- Technical Questions, Answers, Observations => Topic started by: TomJ on July 20, 2011, 10:40:21 AM
-
Here's one that seems common sense to me but I'm still not sure about it. When I pulled the front axles apart on the '51 3A I'm redoing the Bendix universals, upper and lower king-pins were all packed in grease. Now I've read on other posts that those king-pins get lubricant from the spray coming off the universals, my question is, should those universals be packed in grease or lubricated with some sort of gear oil? The thing that made me suspicious at first was the filler plug on the housing, but everything was coated/packed so it all looked like it was protected.
Thanks guys
Tom
-
My front spindle universals are running in tranny oil, 85-90wt EP oil. So far they haven't leaked much if any. My newly rebuilt tranny leaks more than the front axle and the tranny just leaves a few spots on the garage floor.
-
Tom,
You might check out this thread from the old forum on the steering knuckles. It has some very good discussion about what type of fluid to use:
http://cj3apage.proboards.com/index.cgi?board=Tech&action=display&thread=1418
Basically, there are three main options:
-Make your own "knuckle pudding" out of grease and oil
-Use modern CV joint lube
-Use some of the specialty oils/lube available from Penrite or Novaks
http://www.novak-adapt.com/knowledge/steering_knuckle_repair.htm
(Has anyone used this from Novak's? I have thinking of buying some but would like to talk with someone that has used it)
From experience, I can tell you to NOT use 80/90 wt gear oil. Been there, done that and cleaned up the mess left on my garage floor and on my newly painted parts!
-
I found 2 products that might not be too hard to find.
1) I ordered semi-liquid grease from Restoration Supply and received "Lubriplate #1500" I would think that any Lubriplate dealer could order this in for you.
2) I was visiting my local Toro dealer and needed a product for the gearbox on my snowblower. They had "Alco Super Lube 00 Grease" which is also a semi-liquid grease. I believe it was about $7 for the quart.
For what it's worth, I made up a batch of "knuckle puddin'" for my steering gear some time back. It was a real mess getting it into that small hole. I looked in there last month and all I could see was the oil on the top. If I had to guess (and that's pretty much all I do) I'd say that it has separated.
Mark provides a good link to the old forum above, check it out.
-
You can be almost guarateed that the gear oil will get into your front brakes eventually. It will come out along the axle to the hub and then work its way back through the bearings and seals to get into the brakes. My brother found that out the hard way and it didn't take very long. New brake shoes ruined.
-
As usual you guys are great. Checked out the links and the comments on what seems to work and what doesn't. The tips on the semi-liquid grease seems to make alot of sense. I've already repacked and reassembled them but haven't put the hubs on so I can change things if I need to. I have to say that it didn't look like the axles had been touched in a long time (judging by the shape of the gear oil in the pumpkin) and the knuckles looked to be practically new with all the old grease still there. So I guess my thinking is that even if you go with just packing the housing with grease you still provide a good deal of protection. I think I'll fill the rest of the housing with semi-liquid to complement the grease already in there and maybe pull them apart in a few years and see how they hold up.
Tom
-
My front axle apears to be loaded with grease also. I don't know what it is. �The consistency is a bit soupy compared to regular grease, but not as loose as a 50/50 mixture of grease and gear oil. �It's about the consistency of brake grease I guess. �No leaks, and if memory serves, the balls got some lube before I took this thing apart.
If anyone has the Novak product, I would like to know how thick it is.
Tim �
-
If the oil leaks out of the steering knuckle at the large ring seal and at the axle seal perhaps you need to replace the seals.
-
If the oil leaks out of the steering knuckle at the large ring seal and at the axle seal perhaps you need to replace the seals.
That reminds me of a joke I once heard:
Did you hear about the walrus that crashed a tupperware party?
He heard that there were a lot of tight seals!
(Mr. Moderator: Feel free to delete if you think this is inappropriate!) �;)
-
;D That's good. I haven't heard that one.
-
Has anyone used the steering knuckle lube from Novak's?
-
And then there's Corn Head grease.
http://www.greenpartstore.com/John-Deere-Special-Purpose-Corn-Head-Gun-Grease-AN102562.html
http://www.finalube.com/Product_Data_Files/Fina_Branded_PDF_Files/corn_head_grease_no_0.pdf
http://www.frontieraginc.com/Petroleum/Lubricants/Grease/CornHeadGrease.pdf
even on you tube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UEwk_sYP6A8
Appears to be the ideal for the application.
If you're interested, there's a long thread on the 3B forum about it.
http://z4.invisionfree.com/CJ3B_Bulletin_Board/index.php?showtopic=2749
-
My front axle apears to be loaded with grease also. I don't know what it is. �The consistency is a bit soupy compared to regular grease, but not as loose as a 50/50 mixture of grease and gear oil. �It's about the consistency of brake grease I guess. �No leaks, and if memory serves, the balls got some lube before I took this thing apart.
If anyone has the Novak product, I would like to know how thick it is.
Tim �
Hi Tim, I have the Novak product, its pretty thick, especially when cold, On the grease scale it comes in @ #0 grade, semi fluid,
but still flows,
Now its quite a story how I came to find this unusual grease, and did not even start with tying to find it for a Jeep, found it in a Toyota, 1988 Land cruiser, Now I skimmed thru this thread and the folks concerned about getting oil on the brakes when filling the knuckle with oil, Yep the oil will work its way to the wheel hub and mix with the wheel bearing grease,
Now if everything is in tip top shape this wheel hub could contain a oil, but the potential of it getting on the brakes is there,
Now the odd thing about this grease it is used in the wheel hub as well as in the knuckle, the later model replicated axles have up to 2 lube grooves in the bushing to ensure this happens,
Now while it was the Toyota axle that I began to study I quickly realized where it came from and old Jeep information clued me into what was going on here,
This picture shows the two grades used by manufactures, #0 and #1 grade
(http://i739.photobucket.com/albums/xx39/backwoodsgoop/Screenshot2011-07-07at71254AM.png)
Thanks Frank
-
Has anyone used the steering knuckle lube from Novak's?
Yes,
I have been testing this old school Jeep grease in all sorts of wheel hubs, no problems, here it is in a Ford Explorer Wheel hub,
(http://i739.photobucket.com/albums/xx39/backwoodsgoop/PICT05622.jpg)
-
Do you like the Novak product better than the corn header grease? I'm just trying to find the most economical product ;)
-
Do you like the Novak product better than the corn header grease? �I'm just trying to find the most economical product �;)
Corn Head Grease,
Now I have never seen or used the John Deere Grease, if it flows and stays put in this less then oil tight power transmission device then it would be economical, What you have to consider rather then the cost of the grease itself is how well it works in the application it is used in, and how long,
Off the top of my head I believe the Corn head grease is a polyeura or plastic grease for lack of a better term,
The Novak product is Sodium based grease, a rarely seen and seldom used grease as I have seen it described, Incompatible with any other grease, The challenge to find the best grease for this frt axle is that it needs to lubricate a wheel joint, trunnion bearings and wheel bearings,
When researching about this Unique grease used by Jeep and other manufactures it rather easy to see why it was used, first and foremost as mention it is used in areas that are prone to leakage, and in this case with this axle a slight discharge to coat and protect the ball is desired,
It is known to do well in areas that are subjected to severe shock and pounding, have excellent adhesion properties, and where extended service intervals can be obtained,
In this closed knuckle application 30-40 year longevity is common, Wheel hub included, basically limited to the life span of the seals,
This is Economical, so economical that with the known Planned Obsolescence that is common place in the auto trade, your not likely to know about it, You see it was a Toyota dealership that told me this grease was "Private". I was interested to find out why, Now I knew that Domestic axles of this design had been used in years past so began looking in old books about the subject of lubrication , and heres the run down on that, Dana says to use 140 W oil but to follow individual manufactures suggestions,
Ford merely says to use 1/2 a pint of the" Proper Lube" In the Same Book Dodge Says to use "Short Fiber grease" and #2 Multipurpose grease,
International says a "Viscous Chassis lubricant" GMC only says to fill the knuckle with a lubricant for this purpose,
So While Toyota said "Private" and Domestic folks gave me the run around, Jeep however described the base, and the grades used,
Now it has been quite a challenge to find information about this goop used some 70 years ago a great source of information with all sorts of tests and studies was done in the mid 1980,s by the Rail Road and the Texaco oil company, this goop is used in locomotive traction gear motors,
Now I first started to present this information on-line to Toyota Folks that have Mis-diagnosed this proprietary goop as axle seal failure, lets just say that has not gone over so well,
One may wonder how a simple thing such as grease could be so overlooked,
-
Okay,
I have yet to go thru a DANA 25 and document the procedure, But I am doing up a Toyota axle for a "Mudder" Rig,
http://www.backwoodsgoopinfo.com/goopBB/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=39&p=274
-
Hi Frank.
Thanks for the information and the photos. �I know this is a long shot, but can you tell from my photo if I have plain old grease or a #0 level Novak lube? �I am just not sure.
Tim
(http://i1195.photobucket.com/albums/aa397/athawk11/drum20110711axleapart.jpg)
-
Hi Frank.
Thanks for the information and the photos. �I know this is a long shot, but can you tell from my photo if I have plain old grease or a #0 level Novak lube? �I am just not sure.
Tim
(http://i1195.photobucket.com/albums/aa397/athawk11/drum20110711axleapart.jpg)
Your very welcome, It has the appearance of #1 grade grease, So Not regular grease, which is #2 �
It is rather easy to identify grades of grease when you have a known sample to compare, So if you where to go buy a Regular #2 grease and what you have there is "Softer" you can be sure its #1 grade,
Which it sure looks like, but the finger in the grease test is needed to confirm,,
Here is a picture of the grease grades laid out, from #000 to #2 �
(http://i739.photobucket.com/albums/xx39/backwoodsgoop/DSCN5967.jpg)
Typical CV joint grease in the pouch is #1 grade and looks like what you have there,
-
Wow! Great info on the grease! Looks like I will break down and buy the Novak product after all. I had heard about the corn head grease and it was going to be more convinient to buy as there is a dealership close to my house.. ::)
Thanks for posting the photos of the different grades of grease!
-
Wow! �Great info on the grease! �Looks like I will break down and buy the Novak product after all. �I had heard about the corn head grease and it was going to be more convinient to buy as there is a dealership close to my house.. ::)
Thanks for posting the photos of the different grades of grease!
No problem, I have a lot of grease info, been studying it for over 2 years, as well as this enclosed axle design, and its very nice to present this information and have it be well received,
-
http://www.backwoodsgoopinfo.com/goopBB/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=39
Okay Just finished up the overhaul, As soon as I find a neat ol Jeep to do up I will and document the procedure, however more things are the same then is different on these axles,
I do have a 1942 Chevy 1 1/2 Ton Rig to restore, So will get that going one of these days,
(http://i739.photobucket.com/albums/xx39/backwoodsgoop/DSCN5726.jpg)
-
Neat Bob,
Well its Toyota sales that I am after, plain and simple, Recommend a incompatible and incorrect grade of grease in their books,
2 things I have found out about this old school Jeep grease that helps in the things you mention, #1 it absorbs moisture, #2 used in areas that are subjected to severe shocking and pounding,
That causes the brinnelling , or more so shock loading,
Modern CV joint grease is #1 grade, or thinner, and Modern CV joint lube is a contradiction of terms, Frank Rzeppa designed the CV joint in the 20,s for submarines, I would imagine he used a modern CV joint lube, that flowed, or was #1 or thinner,
1920 they had modern CV joint lube,
What is your recommendations in your Book ? Do you specify the same lube in the wheel hub ? a "Modern CV joint lube will work its way thru the spindle and potentially mix with the Wheel bearing grease, Which if different can cause problems,
While I may be blunt but CV joint and or wheel joint lube is not "Modern" I forget the name right off hand of the inventor of the first enclosed steering axle but in his patent he mentioned that his invention allowed for a "properly lubed" Wheel joint, Which @ best would be a "Modern Oil"..
Your term "Modern CV joint lube" is a contradiction, Modern Mercedes Benz and BMW have used oil in CV joints, And Ol Frank back in the 20's used a modern lube as well,
While you do not get caught up in the lube deal for these axles, I do, The worlds leading auto manufacture has taken this design, replicated it, used the same goop, and then the sales company of this automobile writes a book and dupes a entire generation about something as silly as grease,
And it would seem that the leading tech writers of these older rigs have not researched or understand the design as well as the Toyota engineers that replicated this axle in the early 1950.s
This is partially to blame on some "White Propaganda" in the Civilian Jeep books, I can tell by what Toyota changed, and Improved upon if you will what Old Man Willies was up to, back in the day, with his machine built for war,
#0 or #1 in the wheel hub as well, not #2 grade, which is the White propaganda of which I speak,
Frank
-
What many people loose sight of with these old jeep front axles is that the lubricant is not simply a grease for the joint, it is supposed to be light enough that the rotation of the axles will sling it up to the upper kingpin. Stuffing everything with regular #2 or heavier grease will not accomplish that. Oh sure, the seals won't leak but the upper kingpin won't get lubed either. Too much trying to reinvent the wheel, use what the factory specified; #0 (Winter), #1 (Summer).
Larry
-
What many people loose sight of with these old jeep front axles is that the lubricant is not simply a grease for the joint, it is supposed to be light enough that the rotation of the axles will sling it up to the upper kingpin. Stuffing everything with regular #2 or heavier grease will not accomplish that. Oh sure, the seals won't leak but the upper kingpin won't get lubed either. Too much trying to reinvent the wheel, use what the factory specified; #0 (Winter), #1 (Summer).
Larry
Yes Larry, Actually the common failure is the upper trunnion bearing, from #1 incorrect grease and #2 not operating it in 4wd occasionally, As far as #0 or #1 depending on temp,
It certianly does not have to be changed out every other season, More so #1 or #0 depending on application, Full or part time, usage, condition of the axle, I prefer the #0 because it simply has more oil in it, and that provides the lubrication,,