My Willys 3A and 3B Community
Rambling, Malarky, Rants, Etc. => Rambling, Malarky, Rants, Etc... => Topic started by: Carls_jeep on September 06, 2012, 09:53:46 AM
-
In 2008 the dept of interior and BLM made a directive to close all roads to vehicular traffic. It was never implemented but now they are doing it. In San Juan County Ut, as of now ALL ROADS AND TRAILS ON BLM LANDS ARE CLOSED UNLESS MARKED WITH AN OPEN SIGN. It is no longer legal to drive on any BLM lands in San Juan County Ut.
At the meeting the two top managers at the Monticello office gave us permission (in violation of their own rules) to drive the trails. However their officers can arrest and fine us up to $1000 and 1 year in jail if they want to. Calvin and I were suspicious they told us to do it so they can make an example of us.
You can look for all the BLM lands in all the BLM states to be closed by the end of this year. After that you will only be allowed to hike or MAYBE ride a horse. It�s to late to do anything about it, the BLM and the environmentalists have taken the lands away from the citizens of the USA.
I will find the directive and post it for the non believers.
WE HAVE LOST OUR RIGHTS TO DRIVE ON OUR OWN LANDS. IT'S OVER, THEY HAVE WON.
-
This makes me sick. I try not to be political here, but our Federal Government is out of control. Every day, another 'right' is taken away.
What's next? Limiting what I can eat and drink? Oh yah, that's already starting.
I'm so sick of this garbage.
-
I guess I'll take the fine then. ;)
-
Yes, the woman in charge of the whole of BLM in SE Utah told the Blanding City Councilmen that there is no way to reverse the directive from Washington DC. It is written in stone as of now and they are preparing to close them soon.
A very good friend of Calvin's works the counter at BLM Monticello and gave us his used set of maps and said to drive the trails until the hammer falls. The only roads that are shown open on the maps are the San Juan County roads. All of the other roads are closed to vehicular traffic as of now but they are allowing a grace period to finalize everything.
The woman manager from Moab agreed to meet with the Blanding City Council to discuss the roads but she told them it won't change anything and only the County roads will be open for travel. I do believe the Native Americans will still have the right to go any where they want but I am not sure about that because I forgot to ask them about that. They may not be allowed to use vehicles on the BLM lands either.
This may also lead to mine minerals or drill for oil because of no vehicle traffic allowed. It's hard to tell how far they will go to stop everything.
The only hope we have is if the 5 BLM states continue their fight to get the land under their control. The BLM owns 90+% of the land in Nevada, think about that a while. Look up how much land the BLM owns in those 5 states. I say BLM owns the land because after you hear the manager talk it's obvious they think THEY own the land, not the citizens of the USA or the government of the USA.
At the end of last Tuesdays meeting to say I was * is saying it mildly.
WE NEED TO GET RID OF THE DEPT OF INTERIOR AND ALL IT'S SUB GROUPS.
EDIT: Fellows, I too hate to get a political thread started BUT, this is a very important topic to us that like to drive OUR lands the BLM thinks they own. I am sorry it this topic offends anyone but it needs to be discussed. AND, don't take the threat of fines and jail time lightly.
The BLM is using San Juan County Utah as a steeping stone and an example of the rest of the states what is going to happen to them. This directive is for San Juan County now and the rest will follow latter.
As further proof Upper Recapture was temporarily closed for 90 days evaluation 5 YEARS AGO and is still closed. They promised at the meeting to look at it again by March 2013. It will probably remain closed. The Grand Old Broads were the ones that caused Upper Recapture to be closed.
-
Start the CJ3A Search and Rescue. They can't keep you out if someone is lost and some of us could be you know from time to time. I'll volunteer anytime. However we will never be as lost as the mental midget beaurocrats who run the show. The guy I just went to court with in Washington is one of these and he is the head of Fish and Game Dept of Washington. These guys sure don't do much to earn their paycheck, and common sence is never involved it seems.
-
Wow this is a disturbing topic.... First of all to Carl, Calvin, and crew thank you for sharing with us the pictures of your ride. The scenery in your pictures should be in an art display, the jeeps gave it life and purposeful intent. I think that Carl is sadly correct when he states that we have lost. What was a seemingly good idea here in Maine 20 years ago, The Lands for Maine's Future, is now a very well funded (with our tax dollars) environmentalist group that is killing everything from logging to snowmobiling.
In deference to Bill I had better cap it here as I find myself deleting much that I am typing.
I guess it is a common thread that we share in trying to preserve a 60 year old machine that under goverment regulations could not be built today.
Make your vote count in November!!!
-
Don't worry about offending me. I agree with y'all on this one. I lived in Page AZ and during the few years I was there I saw our ability to visit Lake Powell and drive off road cut off completely unless we paid for the privelege. The Navajo naiton did allow a few folks in the res, but unless you were Navajo you could not just go riding for fun.
BLM and the administration at that time also closed a huge amount of Utah to mining, cutting off the economy in the are completely with no recourse whatsoever. At least that is how I remember it happening. At the same time off roading was shut down as I remember it.
Now driving a tow truck I was allowed to go offroad as far as needed to retreive someone or something. Ever see how far a boat can skid without a trailer?? ;D ;D Nothing like off road boating.
Edited to remove a reference to a certain administration.
-
Go to this link for the official Monticello Field Office Travel Plan Maps. There are over 2,820 miles of Class D roads (two �track) open for motorized use within San Juan County.
http://www.blm.gov/ut/st/en/fo/monticello/maps_11__by_17_.html
Tom Heinlein
Monticello Field Office Manager
Bureau of Land Management
Visit the Monticello Field Office at: http://www.blm.gov/ut/st/en/fo/monticello.html
Well Carl, you have opened the door...the above email was sent to me today after I inquired re: your allegations about all roads being off limits and that all BLM lands would be closed in the near future. If you click on any one of the maps, you will see the many roads that are open. If Mr. Heinlein has given me bad information, please tell me so I can inquire further.
The BLM manages many square miles of public lands - 22.9 million acres in Utah alone. They manage to the principals of "multiple use" and cannot please everybody. I know people who work for the BLM and USFS and they are good people. Doing a difficult job as best they can with everybody and their brother screaming at them. I would expect that there are some clerks in their employ who do not really understand all of the issues around road closures and such, and give out misleading or ambiguous information. This is unfortunate. Maybe Carl and Calvin were given some bad information, I don't know. But to allege that all BLM lands are to be off limits to the public defies credulity. To allege that there are no BLM roads open to the public in San Juan county is absurd. To allege that mining and any other resource extraction will become off limits on BLM lands is just fear mongering and has no basis in fact.
Carl, you have made it very clear that you despise "environmentalists". Well, I'll tell you what...I want clean air. I want clean water. I want to have suitable habitat for the wildlife with which we share this planet. Does this make me an environmentalist? Well I guess it would, and you are very clear about how you feel about me.
FBill, are we to understand then, that spewing political *crap on this site is acceptable as long as you agree with the point of view that is doing the spewing? Slippery slope, Bill, and I would hope for better from you. I guess you will be deleting my post.
Tim, you have been a great help to me with my jeep and I thank you, but you seem to have a deep hatred of the government. Seriously, what "rights" have you lost? Are you referring to Bush's "Patriot Act"? Maybe Bush's "Homeland Security Act"? Maybe Bush's "TSA"? Given your comment re: junk food, I guess you feel the Feds should have never regulated or taxed tobacco and smoking or alcohol???
Bob W., the "Blue Ribbon Coalition" sucks! They are not our best ally - they fight all reasonable remedies to the very contentious issues re: motorized recreation on public lands. Dig deeper.
C'mon guys...this is a site for those of us who like old Willys jeeps. I come here to escape - not to be preached to about all that is wrong with the world. Bill, if your intention is to have this site be only used by the far right on the political spectrum - if we have to hate the government, and go through life as victims of the government and blame the government for all that is wrong in our lives, then you should state that clearly under "members information" or somewhere.
When I first started using the CJ3A page four years ago I only used the "Tech" section as that is what I needed help with while building my 3a. As I got to "know" many of you (and like many of you), I started to read all of the other sections, including the "rants" section. But sometimes it is a challenge to suffer through some of the BS. Sorry guys, I know I'm all alone here out on this limb and you can "black ball" me if you want to, but I just can't suffer you're *crap anymore. Every time there is a holiday of some sort (especially a military holiday) you have to get in your licks against the government. I think it is time to "nut up" - if there are things wrong in your lives, change those circumstances. Stop whining about how you are victims of "the government".
-
Tom, I have that map given to me by the office in Monticello. Every road on that map is a San Juan County road, there are no dirt BLM roads on that map. That map show the roads that are legal to drive on and it's only COUNTY ROADS MAINTAINED BY THE COUNTY. The BLM closed all their roads unless marked open and none of them are marked open or closed at this time.
I too like clean air and clean water and good fishing and good hunting. What I don't like is overbearing people with lots of money telling someone else they can't do something just because THEY don't want to do it. Most environmentalists are not reasonable and tend to be extreme. I am in the center. I want everyone to enjoy everything in the USA and save it for the future. Closing Jeep trails serves no one but the environmentalists. It does not serve the general public in any way.
This topic is being discussed on the CJ2 and CJ3 site and the reason I did it is to make all Jeepers aware of what our government is doing to us. They are taking away the use of our lands.
I am going to post something I put on the CJ2 site below perhaps that will clear some things.
EDIT: The Class B and D roads that Tom said are open are COUNTY ROADS, the BLM doesn't use class numbers on their roads. That map is a total lie by the BLM, it's a farce to make people like you think everything is just fine.
-
Well, that is true, the people here tell me that all the ruts and trails are smoothed over with the winter and spring rains. The County highway dept has to go out and reconstruct the roads nature has obliterated. They tell me that if a Jeep trail on dirt in the BLM lands isn't used every year then in two years it can seldom be found on the ground and the only way to find it is by flying over and looking for the open tree path. It is almost invisible on the ground.
The weather causes more erosion problems than Jeeps, ATV's or motorcycles. I was told and saw for myself that storms will wash out a road so what was a slight dip in the road is now a gully and can't be crossed.
At the meeting of the BLM and Blanding city council Tuesday night. The head of the local BLM told the council all the roads on BLM land in San Juan County are closed except the county roads unless marked open. She later said that the roads are all open unless marked closed. The council members said, you can't have it both ways, your policy statement says the roads are closed unless marked open and your telling us it's both ways so which is it? She told them the roads are open unless marked closed and that is not what the BLM policy statement she presented said.
After the meeting closed I confronted Shelley Smith, Canyon County District Manager, and Tom Heinlein, Field Office Manager and told them I had just trailered my Jeep 1700 miles to drive the Jeep trails on the BLM land and now your telling me they are closed. She said no you can drive on them unless there is a closed sign. I said but you just said in the meeting they are closed unless marked open so which way is it. She said they are open, drive on them.
That is against the Federal policy that she and Tom are hired to enforce so she is telling be to break the law. Calvin and I then contacted the County Sheriff and he came by Calvin's home and after some discussion gave us his cell phone number and told us to do as she said and if we are stopped to call him or tell them to contact him by radio and he will take care of it.
So far I have driven on several BLM roads and nothing has happened and I hope it doesn't but my thoughts are this is the last year anyone will be driving on BLM lands in San Juan County. San Juan County is a test bed and when they close the roads here it won't be long before ALL BLM roads in all 5 BLM states will be closed.
The Grand Old Broads are coming to San Juan County Sept 27 to Oct 1 to celebrate their success in getting the BLM lands closed.
If you think any policy directive of the BLM can be changed your wrong. About 5 years ago the Upper Recapture Canyon was closed for a 6 month test period by efforts of the Grand Old Broads. The BLM promised to review it at the end of the 6 months. It has not been reviewed for 5 years and at the Monday meeting Tom Heinlein promised to review it and have a decision by March 2013. No one at the meeting believed him because it's been promised before. The problem is, he is leaving this office this November.
I am going to enjoy all the trails I can because I don't expect them to be open next year.
-
Tom, Calvin, I and about 15 other Jeep trail riders were at that meeting where Shelley and Tom waffled back and forth on closed and open. The fact is they have no power to close County roads and they know it and that's why only County roads appear on their map. They don't have ANY BLM roads on their "MAP". The dirt roads on BLM land that the County does not maintain nor by law can maintain from County funds are not on any map given to the public. The BLM can't spend money on County roads and the County can't spend County money on BLM roads.
Tom and Shelley stood there in that room and told all of us to drive on the BLM roads all we want. They said if we don't go off the road track we are ok. I asked what do I do if I want to stop and climb to look at something, do I leave my Jeep in the middle of the dirt road knowing you can't get off that trail. He said if I want to park for a while to pull off in a clear spot and leave it there. As long as I don't drive well off the road I am ok. I am following their word even though I KNOW it's against the law but the Sheriff is on our side so I will let them fight it out. The Sheriff is already * off at them anyway and just wants an excuse to give them a fight. At first they wanted to take all the dirt County roads away from the County but there is an old law against doing that.
This is a dirty war and it's going to get dirtier the more Jeep and ATV riders find out about it.
I respect your right to be an environmentalist and assist in taking away the rights of the public but I am not going to stand by and let it happen without a fight.
I love this world that the Creator gave us and I want to protect it and ENJOY IT, not just look at it from afar.
Your better off if you don't believe everything a politician, government official or employee tells you. I was at that meeting and saw them lie with my own eyes and ears. I am also heavily involved in the County government in Spencer Co. Ky and I personally know how much they lie and misrepresent things to get their way. �
-
Bob W., �the "Blue Ribbon Coalition" sucks! �They are not our best ally - they fight all reasonable remedies to the very contentious issues re: motorized recreation on public lands. �Dig deeper
Help me out here. Who is our best ally for responsible use of off pavement roads on public land?
-
Asking the BLM if they are guilty of something is like asking the Fox is he is killing your chickens when he has feathers on his mouth. If you want the truth of what is happening in San Juan County contact the Blanding city council, the Monticello city council, the San Juan commissioners and SPEAR, a local off road group trying to save the BLM lands for off road driving.
The truth of the matter is I am here and your not and I can see first hand what is happening. The government and the environmentalists are robbing the citizens of the USA the free use of the public lands.
I started this thread to make all of you aware what our government is doing to us, open yours eyes, read, ask the people that are being affected, not just the ones trying to control us.
This is not a political thread, this is a civil rights thread for anyone interested in keeping our rights to our public lands.
-
Is there a national level off-road organization that can deal with the federal government?
I guess we're talking a group able to lobby in DC like all the other special interest groups.
I understand how emotions can get hot over issues like this. It's best for all of us to try to moderate the rhetoric and stick to facts and personal witness. This is a very important issue for all of us - and not just off-roaders. I'm an active paddler as well (canoe and kayak) and am seeing the same thing happening in that arena. There are battles going on over paddling access to stretches of certain rivers. The sad thing is that some of the battling is between users, not between the users and the government. There are some rather dirty fights going on over parts of rivers between paddlers and fishermen. That's very sad, as we should all be cooperating to retain access to the "wilderness" rather than fighting over it.
If there is a national group that can be our advocate in DC, we need to know who it is and support it. And we need to be active at the local level as well, supporting our local law enforcement and especially working with them to clean out the bad apples who, in many cases, have started this whole mess by abusing the access privileges we've had in the past. Every off-road area has jerks who think they can drive wherever they want with no consequences. We need to work with local law, and the Feds, to police our own.
But the real work is at the Federal level.
My $0.02 worth.
-
I'm sorry to see my CJ-3A brethren at each others' throats. �Like Tom said, I come here to enjoy the posts and reminisce a little. �It's troubling to see the infighting as emotions surface. �My dear mother, God rest her soul, often said that when you have a bucket of sh*t, the more you stir it the more it stinks. �However, not just because Carl is my friend, but because I was born and raised here in San Juan County, Utah, that I feel I should add to this thread. �Even as a teenager I had three different Jeeps (pics and narrative of them are posted on a much earlier thread). With those Jeeps I drove the the mountains, canyons and deserts of this beautiful American Southwest landscape. �This is home to me. �Like my father before me and his father before him, I love this land. �I have a close friend (who owns a CJ-3A and drives the locals trails, too), whose grandfather was a leader in the pioneering group to first arrive in San Juan and established the first settlement here. �Those of us whose very roots are here, and who have loved and cared for this beautiful county since the very first arrival of the white man, don't like it when others who were born, raised, and educated elsewhere come here as BLM agents to tell how to care for our land and do so by closing our roads and tell us it's to protect the natural resources. �I've seen trail after trail posted "CLOSED" by the BLM over the past few years and our freedom to visit places we have gone to with our families for years is taken from us. �The BLM document closing all roads unless posted "OPEN" does exist. �As Carl has stated, we were given verbal permission in the City Council/BLM meeting on 4th of this month to drive the roads not physically posted "CLOSED". �But, because of the BLM document, we don't know how long that "verbal" permission will last. Please wish us well. �
-
Guys, I beleive we all here want to see our off road rights preserved. I don't think this needs to be a left wing right wing thing, and I really do not see too many examples of this. Perhaps I should not have mentioned the Clintons in my little note I made last night after a long day on the road.
As far as deleting your post, Tom. I won't do that. I wasn't even thinking about it. Besides, Sparky and Annie tell me you are a good guy, despite the fact that you don't feed them steak quite often enough for their tastes. Perhaps you might want to PM me next time you have a problem with right wing BS here, so I can also identify what exactly you are referring to. Maybe give me a chance to moderate before you blast anyone. Just a suggestion. I still consider you a jeep friend, and appreciate your contributions to this site. Things like your statement about the Blue Ribbon Coalition interest me, as just hearing the conservative side will not as you know, give the entire story.
There are always two sides for every story. The truth lies somewhere between , especially in this case.
That said, we have promised to keep politics and religion off this site, or at the very least at a bare minimum. I won't lock this thread but I do ask that we keep on topic re land closing and the BLM/Forest Service/ and our jeeps. There are a few statements above that might want to be retracted or edited but I will leave that up to the responsible authors, and if there are any more statements about moderation to be made, please PM me or John. John, you have my blessing to delete stuff if it goes too far. Please PM the authors to tell them what you have to do and why....
I need to get back to work, as I am typing this at a truck stop in Tribune KS, with minimal WIFI services. �Please behave and play nice guys. �8-)
-
Incremental change. That is how the government takes our public lands rights away. They make an announcement, generally disguised as a "proposal", like the closing of BLM roads in a certain area that has been discussed here, knowing that it will stir up a hornets nest. They fully expect the reaction they get. They know it's coming. Then, in apparent consideration of the public reaction, they back off and let things settle down. Then, after enough time has passed, they bring it up again. If the reaction is still strong enough they back off again. This is repeated until they feel that enough people have become sufficiently conditioned to the their proposal (read: loss of more rights), and have finally grown tired of the fight. That is when the shoe drops, the "proposal" is enacted, and the public has lost another freedom. And it is lost forever. I have seen this happen over and over and over again.
I have watched the Forest Service use these exact tactics for the last 40 years here where I live, in the Plumas National Forest, CA. Every year there is another turn of the screw. They have eliminated hundreds of miles of roads, either by obliterating them, bulldozing a berm, or posting with a sign. They are doing it incrementally, a few more roads every year. Some of these roads have been used for 75 years or more. We have now reached the point where we can not get a vehicle off of a dirt road when parking....for any reason. Where we used to be able to cut any dead or down tree for firewood, we are now restricted to only cutting trees that are within 100 feet of the road. All the rest of the tens of thousands of dead trees can fall over and rot away, but they cannot be used for firewood. It has taken decades for the environmentalists that now infest the Forest Service in my county to totally hamstring people who cut firewood to heat their homes. Now that firewood cutting almost a thing of the past, the new target is snowmobilers. Just this summer a huge, I mean huge, chunck of land is "proposed" to become off limits to snowmobilers, and all other vehicular traffic, because there are 3 pairs of Bald Eagles that nest in the area. The first public meeting has been held, and the expected public outrage has been expressed. Of course the Bald Eagles are a straw man argument, but that is all the Forest Service needs. One wonders how these eagles established their nests with the snowmobilers using the area. The nests weren't there 15 years ago. The local Forest Service apparently considers our national forest to be their personal property, and they would be happy if the public would just stay out of it. And every year they take another small step to accomplish their goal.
It is not just a figment of our imagination that we are slowly losing our freedoms on our "public" lands. It is happening. A person can defend the government if they so choose, and maintain that the feelings expressed here and elsewhere are just paranoia, and an unjustified hatred of environmentalists. If there are people who intensely dislike environmentalists it is not because envirnmentalists want "clean air", "clean water", and a world where animals can continue to exist. Who doesn't want these things? Environmentalists also want to prohibit , or outlaw, activities that they personally dislike. That is why so many people dislike them. They use their influence to get our government agencies to get what they want. There is no denying that we have less freedoms on our public lands than we had just a few decades ago. If the government did not take these freedoms away, then who did?
The BLM might postpone the actions that have been discussed here, if there is sufficient outrage, or they might just close a "few" roads. Then next year or the year after they might close a few more roads. They know that delay and patience can soften the blow, and make their actions seem less dictatorial, unnecessary, and arbitrary. That's the beauty of incremental change, and why it is so effective.
Anyone who thinks that the BLM cannot or would not do these things is dreaming. Let the doubters bring their jeep to the Plumas National Forest and park it 20 feet off the road to be safely clear of traffic and dust. And then when one of our friendly, gun toting USFS individuals comes by and writes them a ticket they can tell me that the fears that have been expressed here are *crap." If, 25 years ago somebody had said this would happen, it would have been laughed off as impossible. If, 25 years ago, somebody had said that a dead tree within archery range of a road could no longer be cut for firewood it would have been laughed off as impossible.
When it comes to fearing the impossible, where our goverment is concerned, it is not *crap". It is fear borne of experience.
-
Tom, with all do respect, I don't 'hate' our government. �Governments at all levels play a very important role in our lives. �They are critical in protecting my rights and my safety. �It would be nice if we didn't need a government, but without it, the 'rule of law' could not, and would not exist. �Unfortunately, human nature can sometimes be very cruel.
I am happy to pay my share of taxes, for without them, we don't have a military, police, infrastructure etc... �
I've grown to rely on, and expect these things from my country.
What I don't like is when a government, at any level, steps in and picks 'winners' and 'losers'. �Especially, with regard to markets and economic issues. �This happens far too frequently. �You and I should be picking the winners and losers...with our dollars.
Socially, I'm a live...and let live guy. �I could care less what people do...as long as they don't infringe on my personal rights.
I don't hate government. I am suspicious of it. �Repubs, Dems, Libertarian ... it doesn't matter which. �I believe they all have good intentions at the beginning. �But for some reason, they change. �I don't know if it's the money, the power, or�
Like many other folks here, when I read that the BLM wants to limit access to "our" land, I get suspicious, yet I understand the intention. �But punishing everyone, when a few bad apples tear up some land seems �extreme� to me. �Why are my rights diminished when some other * acts badly? �Once again, it appears that the government is picking a winner (environmentalists) and a loser (you and I). �
I have never been on a 4 wheel drive trip with anyone that doesn�t have a true love for our environment. �Protecting this land is important to me, but at what cost? �Knowing there is beautiful country to experience, but having to peer at it from the other side of a locked gate? �It just doesn�t make sense.
Tom, with all this said, I hope we are still friends. �I respect your feelings on this matter, and will defend your right to have dissenting views. �Good or bad, I am hopeful that you have a better understanding of my position. �
Tim
-
Here's what a forest service guy has to say on the matter.. M38 Mike, a recent participant in the Alaska convoy and also owner of the Electro-Willys, a modified M38 that runs on batteries. He also is hosting the Fall colors tour again this year, so he knows of what he speaks about jeep trails.
I'd like to add my 2 cents to this discussion. �I work for the FS now as a project planner for the San Isabel NF. �I am a strong proponent of keeping roads open, multiple use, and wise use for resource extraction. �I have been watching, and fighting from within, the slow removal of the multiple use concept that the Forest Service was originally based on. �The public groups that use national forests are getting more and more polarized. �Unfortunately the environmental preservationists are decades ahead of most other groups in learning how to gather support and influence policy. �I'm sad to say that many of the folks who now are in leadership positions in my agency are not leaning toward multiple use, but toward restricted use for much of the national forest system lands.
�
What's happening nationwide is a groundswell of protectionism. �The way to combat that is to get active in motorized recreation organizations. �Even if it's just a basic membership. �That gives the group numbers, and numbers matter on the balance beam of decision making for land management. �When we meet with opposing groups to talk about land management, one person's opinion is small next to the opinion of an organization that has dozens or hundreds of members. �
One of the problems we face in land management is what we call a user-created route. �That's where somebody drives their vehicle straight up the side of a hill just to see if he can do it. �He leaves tracks behind that someone else then follows, and someone else, and someone else. �Pretty soon, in our dry climate you have a two-track road going straight up the side of a hill. �And when the rains do come, they tend to come hard. �That road now becomes a wash out gully. �That's hard to repair and may take decades to heal. �
What we are trying to do is to create routes that will not wash away when we make new roads or trails. �With good design we can access the back country with roads and trails that will remain for decades with little maintenance. �We are working with ATV and Jeep groups to build new routes. �Or to rebuild old ones that are eroding. �But it takes volunteer effort to get it done. �Our declining budgets don't have much maintenance money left in them. �In Colorado the Forest Service gets to benefit from literally tens of thousands of volunteer hours of work each year, both motorized and non-motorized, to keep trails open and repaired. �
But we are also a battleground. �The preservationists want all roads eliminated. �They don't care about fire protection, or disabled recreationists, or the jobs lost by locking up forestland. �They don't live here. �In fact most of them don't even hike here. �They simply want to impose thier will on the rest of us. �And they do it by launching missles at us from courts in distant cities. �In the end, the court will tell us what we can do, and what we can't do. �Not from a resource management professional's perspective, but from the perspective of who won the legal tug of war. �Our Nation Forest is in Denver Federal Court right now with one of those lawsuits challenging over 750 miles of road. �Some of those roads were there before most of us were born. �The fight isn't logical. �But it is comprehensive. �And for our part we are doing all we can to show the court the documents that prove each of those miles of road has a purpose for being there, and was intended for public use. �It's a significant battle. �And it leads to loads of frustration on our part. �
So Carlsjeep, I can feel your frustration and anger. �I get it too. �Perhaps even more so because I get to see how some of these decisions are being made. END OF QUOTE
-
Bedrock and athawk11, those are my feeling to. I don't hate environmentalists or the government but the truth is both are extremists. They do not compromise, it's there way or the highway. I have talked to many friends that are environmentalists and animal rights people. They do not ever see a middle ground my opinion or feelings carries no weight.
The problem is they spent money to hire lawyers and lobbyists to deal with the government at local, state and federal while those that want moderation and use of the land and hunting and fishing do not hire lawyers and lobbyists. We assume everything will be moderated by the government. But money moves the government and if you give them enough money they move for your side of the issue.
I don't HATE anybody for what they believe in, I dislike it when because they don't like what I am doing and it's still legal to do it they want to force me to stop.
The environmentalists and federal government are violating the very foundation concept of our Constitution and stealing or rights every time they can and we seldom fight back. We don't have the time or money and we don't believe the government would do things like that to us.
Well, they did and they are. Goodbye Constitution and Bill of Rights. :(
-
Again I ask.
Is there a nationwide organization of "wilderness users" that can lobby at the Federal level?
Is Tread Lightly that group?
Or the Blue Ribbon Coalition?
Or?
And if not, why not?
We need to band together - Jeepers, ATVers, dirt bikers, hunters, fishermen, all who use motorized transport to access the "wilderness".
We need to feed support to those who can combat the opposition in DC and in the courts.
We need to police ourselves by busting those who break the rules in the off-road areas. Turn them in to the police with video whenever possible. Most local law guys appreciate help.
So again - does such an organization already exist? And if so, is it effective?
-
http://www.sharetrails.org/
http://www.arra-access.com/site/PageServer
http://www.usaall.org/
These are the only ones I know about. I suggest you join each one and donate as much as you can afford OR, pick the one you think works the hardest and putting all your money with them.
-
Just so you know, the first link is to the Blue Ribbon Coalition. After Tom's comment about them I did some digging and found several articles linking the BRC to Big Oil and Mining interest funding sources. HOWEVER I could not find anythng verifying that anywhere yet. and there were some real truth stretchers elsewhere in the same articles. It wouldn't be beyond Big Oil to fund some ORV organizations but some of the statements were so flat wrong about us 4 x 4 users.....that it lent no credulity to what was said. It seems the mudlslinging is not limited to just our tires. There are those out there who equate jeep use with non socially acceptable behavior....and are trying to legislate total elimination of off road use of public lands, using "socially sustainable use" as a landmark.
Please try to stick to the facts as we continue this discussion guys.. Some of you may still need to go back and edit your previous posts..personal attacks, generalizations about certain political leanings, etc, have no place here.
And those of you that do still have access to public lands and places like the power lines......please be responsible. It just takes one idiot bonehead to paint us all with the same brush.
Where would Ansel Adams have been today with such limited access to those wonderful places he photographed?
-
F Bill, I have thought about what you said about the BRC and I have no problems donating to them if they are fighting for our trail rights. The Fact that the environmentalists have an overwhelming number of organizations and huge sums of money to hire lawyers and lobbyists takes away any bad feelings of the motives of anyone fighting for trail rights. We trail riders are small in number compared to the preservationists and environmentalists that want to close the BLM lands to no trespass at all or just hiking.
The fact is all the BLM trails are closed in San Juan County now but against their law they gave us permission to drive them for now. They can pull the plug anytime and will. It's not a maybe it's a done deal and San Juan County is a test of the 2008 law. When they close San Juan the rest will follow real soon.
Having listened to Shelley and Tom from the BLM we both feel this is the last time we will be able to drive on anything but the County maintained roads and the BLM wants to close those roads too. They have already tried but the Counties in Utah have been fighting them over that.